I received this e-mail as a part of a service for African American businesses. The forum sponsored by UnitedHealthCare looks like United really cares and they do but only about their bottom dollar. It makes me ill to see UnitedHealth doing this kind of event when their heart is not in it. All they want to do is to look good and make statements about what they should do (but don't).
Jerry Clark Founder & Chief Executive We Care Minnesota 'An Unaffiliated Group of People, United by the Epidemic of AIDS!" Creating and sustaining an accepting and caring community for all. 118 Cook Avenue West Saint Paul, MN 55117-4931 651-488-1821 (Phone/Fax) wecare@...
Subject: ADV: PR: First-Ever "Essence Health Pavilion" In New Orleans
Distributed through BlackPR.com and BlackNews.com To unsubscribe, follow the instructions at the bottom of this email.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE July 1, 2009
CONTACT: Corliss Hill UnitedHealthcare 770-613-4792 corliss.hill@...
Ann Wills Keating Magee 504-299-7168 or 504-494-3810 (cell) awills@...
UNITEDHEALTHCARE® PARTNERS WITH ESSENCE MUSIC FESTIVAL TO SPONSOR FIRST-EVER “ESSENCE HEALTH PAVILION” JULY 3-5 IN NEW ORLEANS
Complimentary health screenings, LIVE fitness demos by Donna Richardson-Joyner, gifts and prizes to be offered to local community and Festival attendees
New Orleans, LA (BlackNews.com) -- As part of its ongoing commitment to help improve the health status of African Americans, UnitedHealthcare has teamed up with the world-renowned Essence Music Festival to co-sponsor the first-ever Essence Health Pavilion taking place July 3 - 5 in New Orleans, Louisiana. Nearly 160,000 attendees from across the country are expected for the 15th anniversary of the three-day Essence Music Festival event. The 2009 Essence Health Pavilion is co-sponsored by AARP and Susan G. Komen for the Cure's® Circle of Promise.
In conjunction with the Essence Empowerment Seminars, which serve as the daytime destination for festival attendees, delivering compelling and inspirational messages by some of the nation's most renowned leaders, celebrities and music artists, the Essence Health Pavilion is offering the Greater New Orleans community and Festival attendees an array of wellness activities. UnitedHealthcare's Generations of Wellness and Medicare Solutions initiatives will provide festivalgoers complimentary health screenings (blood pressure and cholesterol) from 9:30 a.m. - 12 noon each day; information about affordable healthcare & wellness options for both business owners and seniors; and a chance for small business owners to win prizes at the top of every hour (from 12 noon – 5 p.m.) in the “Whirlwind of Prizes” game. Additionally, attendees will be treated to two very special fitness demonstrations by Donna Richardson-Joyner, creator of “Sweating in the Spirit,” the #1 Inspirational Fitness Workout Video in the nation, and wife of the #1 Syndicated Radio Talk Show host, Tom Joyner. The LIVE fitness demonstrations take place on the Expo Experience Stage and are co-sponsored by UnitedHealthcare and AARP. They are:
“Get Fit Through Dance” Friday, July 3 at 10 a.m.
“Practical Fitness Tips for Everyday Healthy Living!“ Saturday, July 4 at 10 a.m.
The Essence Empowerment Seminars and all activities in the Essence Health Pavilion take place at the New Orleans Ernest N. Morial Convention Center located at 900 Convention Center Blvd., Hall C, and are free of charge and open to the public on a first come, first served basis.
“UnitedHealthcare, along with AARP and Susan G. Komen for the Cure's® Circle of Promise, is pleased to partner with Essence on such an important initiative as improving the health outcomes and economic forecast for African Americans,” says Corliss Hill, national multicultural marketing director for UnitedHealthcare. “We are excited to host the Essence Health Pavilion as part of this year's 15th anniversary event.”
Generations of Wellness targets effective health care communication in the belief that it will drive earlier identification, treatment and outcomes for heart disease, stroke, cancer, diabetes and asthma, the top five diseases that disproportionately impact African Americans.
About UnitedHealthcare UnitedHealthcare (www.unitedhealthcare.com) provides a full spectrum of consumer-oriented health benefit plans and services to individuals, public sector employers and businesses of all sizes, including more than half of the Fortune 100 companies. The company organizes access to quality, affordable health care services on behalf of more than 26 million individual consumers, contracting directly with approximately 590,000 physicians and care professionals and more than 4,900 hospitals to offer them broad, convenient access to services nationwide. UnitedHealthcare is one of the businesses of UnitedHealth Group (NYSE: UNH), a diversified Fortune 50 health and well-being company.
About Generations of Wellness Generations of Wellness is focused on providing African Americans with access to quality, affordable health care services through small and mid-size employers, through collaborative efforts that address the health and well-being of African Americans, and by working with business and faith-based organizations to share educational information. To learn more about Generations of Wellness, please visit www.uhcgenerations.com.
About Ovations Ovations is one of six business units that constitute UnitedHealth Group, a Fortune 50 company helping individuals, families and communities improve their health and well-being at all stages of life. Ovations is dedicated to serving the growing health needs of individuals over age 50.
-END-
This information has been distributed through BlackPR.com - an extensive press release distribution service to all the African-American newspapers, magazines, radio and TV stations; and BlackNews.com - an online portal for African-American news & issues.
Diversity City Media | 750-Q Cross Pointe Road | Columbus | OH | 43230
No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 8.5.375 / Virus Database: 270.13.2/2213 - Release Date: 07/01/09 18:07:00
Hi Everyone,
I think all of us who tabled at the UHCAN-MN booth at the Pride LGBT
Festival
thought it went successfully. I especially want to thank several
volunteers
who really did amazing ed/outreach and held the booth down against
ferocious winds. They are: Carol Halonen, Carol Perko, Harry
Greenberg, Beth shapiro, Dori Ullman, Wendy Thoren, Danene
Provenchar, joel albers. 60 people signed up for the list serve or
phone tree, and 100s got informational flyers. $30
in donations.
Nearly all MN major HMO insurers, and some national also tabled at
Pride: Blue Cross, UCare, Medica, Cigna. They gave out everything
from tote bags to pens, key chains, the works. Of course they were
there to market themselves and attract enrollees. The fact is though,
their marketing practices amount to organized deception. Unlike us, i
would bet their tablers were paid staff (maybe even overtime), and
the promotional freebees weren't exactly free. On the contrary, we
are paying for it all through our premiums. And marketing is the
second highest administrative cost, only to billing. So what could be
going to health care service, goes to marketing.
Their PR is designed to make the public believe HMO insurers are an
intrinsic part of the health care system, and your best pal. What HMO
insurers do in practice has actually been harmful to people denied
coverage due to HIV or AIDS. But for the GLBT community and hosts of
the festival, the insurers have not been their best friend. I would
assume that there's all kinds of discrimination of lesbian, gay,
bisexual, and transgendered people applying for or experiencing their
policies. Before it had to be outlawed in MN, women were
discriminated against in health insurance policies and probably still
are. Age is still a discriminatory factor in premium rates. It would
be interesting to study this further, to what degree the GLBT
community is restricted or denied coverage, or costs more. so much
for "Our Rights, Your Rights, Human rights, and i would add, health
care rights.
thanks,
joel
Hi Everybody,
July 1:
Keith Ellison Forum on Solving the Health Care Crisis, wed, 6-8PM, at
UCare (coincidentally, i guess), 500 Stinson Blvd NE, Mpls, 55413.
It's a lot about organizing so if anyone from UHCAN-MN can get there
and represent UHCAN-MN that would be great. Let me know asap, and i
can give you any necessary background. I can get you our new flyer
listing various ways to get involved.
July 6th:
Cookout/UHCAN-MN mtg: Monday, 6:30PM, at Joel's house, 3500 35th Avs
S., Longfellow neighborhood, Mpls 55406. (directions:Take Lake street
to 35th ave and go south to 35th street. Or take Hiawatha (hwy55) to
35th street and go east to 35th ave.) I will supply a grill,
hamburger and hot dog buns, ice tea, utensils,plates. Bring potluck
food/ drink item, esp something to grill.
July 8th:
UHCAN-MN News Conference, wed, 10:30 am, Schneider Drug (on 3800
university ave SE across from KSTP and near I 280, mpls, 55414). the
theme based on our discussions is: 1. the crucial need for a single-
payer health care system 2. OUR criteria for a "public Medicare
option" (one that will emerge into SP) and 3. the need for a state
single-payer option. Speakers so far include:Congressman Keith Ellison (his
staff) Mike Cavlan, Joel Clemmer (MN Health Plan bill for SP), Tom Sengupta
(pharmacist, small
business owner), and Bernie Hess (UFCW labor union). Open to
endorsing organizations which gets your organization on the press
release etc, and entitles you to send a speaker to it.
I think July 4 would be a good day for activists to declare a war of independence to liberate themselves from the shackles of health care slavery. Slaves, revolt against your enslavers, the uniquely American health "insurance" industrialists (such misery they have manufactured for us!).
Your fellow health care slave,
Diane J. Peterson White Bear Lake, Minnesota birch7@...
No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 8.5.375 / Virus Database: 270.12.92/2203 - Release Date: 06/26/09 05:53:00
Below is McCollum's announcement of a Health Care Town Hall this Wednesday, July
1 in Highland Park in St. Paul. My guess is that this event will draw a larger
crowd, and more media coverage, than the press conference at Schneider Drug.
June 17, 2009 - McCollum Invites Constituents To Health Care Town Hall on July 1
Washington, DC – As Congress prepares to reform America's health care system,
Congresswoman Betty McCollum (MN-04) will host a town hall meeting on Wednesday,
July 1 from 6-7:30pm at the Highland Park Picnic Pavilion in St. Paul. All
residents of the Fourth Congressional District are invited to participate and
share their views on reforms to offer the choice of affordable health care to
all Americans.
Event: Health Care Town Hall Meeting with Congresswoman Betty McCollum
Date: Wednesday, July 1, 6-7:30 pm CDT
Location: Highland Park Picnic Pavilion
1270 Montreal Avenue, St. Paul, MN 55116
Congresswoman Betty McCollum (MN-4) serves on the House Appropriations & Budget
Committees.
# # #
Big thanks to Roger Cuthbertson for risking arrest, and in fact, getting arrested, in dignified way, and spending time in jail, resulting from our United Health group protest. This is not an easy thing to do, and takes some sacrifice. Roger finds ways to protest by land, by air (his kite), and by water (by boat). Thanks to one able and inspiring dude.
BTW, the UHCAN-MN news conference for: 1.single-payer, 2.this is what a real public option looks like, and 3. our proposal for a state-level single-payer option, will be wed, july 8th, 10:30am, at Schneider Drug, 3800 university ave, across from KSTP TV, not far from i 280.
If you have a burning desire to speak at it pls let me know, esp if you have a personal story to share. So far we have joel clemmer (MN Health Plan), Bernie Hess (labor union), Mike Cavlan (forming a new political party, stay tuned), Tom Sengupta (pharmacist, small business owner).
More practitioners would be good, so let me know.
thanks much,
joel
On Jun 26, 2009, at 10:09 PM, Roger Cuthbertson wrote:
I'm out of jail and don't have other plans for the 5th, so I could be there, especially if the conference is in the afternoon. Wed, the8th would be good, too. Roger Cuthbertson
Subject:[uhcan-mn] proposal to hold news conference
Hi Everyone,
the drive for health care reform is about as scorching as the weather. So to build on it, and follow-up on the great coverage we got post single-payer rally at the big HMO, in the Star Tribune (almost unheard of on the front page of the business section), i would like to suggest that we strike again while the fire's hot in the form of a news conference.
Tom Sengupta, from Schneider Drug Store has already indicated we could have it at his pharmacy (where i also practice). So if we do a news conference we have a venue. It is right across the street from kstp ch 5, so that can't hurt. If so, would Wed July 8th be ok ?
i put some feelers out for speakers, and we could use more. Let me know.
The framing, messaging, and talking points would be our bread and butter: HC as a public good, single-payer medicare for all, a public option on OUR terms, and also, and this is important, a state single-payer option ( any state that opts for single-payer can do so). a state single-payer option may be a way of getting single-payer in the debate through the back door, window, or chimney. the state single- payer option was actually introduced early in 1993 as part of the national debate, but quickly scuttled.
So pls give me feedback as to whether folks are down with this , or not.
Also, if you can do any tabling at the Pride Festival for UHCAN-MN this weekend, let me know as soon as possible.
Hi Wendy,
i will try to make a lot of flyers (4 to a page) for distribution
during the Pride Parade which begins at 11am at 3rd and Hennepin.
125,000 turnout expected just for the parade. Feel free to join me to
do so. (others welcome to join us to distribute single-payer flyers,
let me know. Should we just say meet-up at Hennepin and 4th, NE corner ?
The UHCAN-MN booth is all set up at Loring Park (with the other 412
booths around the park). Our booth is located on the south side of
(but not in) the tennis court (good landmark). Kindof across the
street from where the old Loring Bar used to be.
Otherwise, so far Carol P, Ann, Carol H, Harry, Beth (i believe) and
myself will be tabling.
as it is said, happy Pride,
joel
I'm out of jail and don't have other plans for the 5th, so I could be there, especially if the conference is in the afternoon. Wed, the8th would be good, too. Roger Cuthbertson
Subject: [uhcan-mn] proposal to hold news conference
Hi Everyone,
the drive for health care reform is about as scorching as the weather. So to build on it, and follow-up on the great coverage we got post single-payer rally at the big HMO, in the Star Tribune (almost unheard of on the front page of the business section), i would like to suggest that we strike again while the fire's hot in the form of a news conference.
Tom Sengupta, from Schneider Drug Store has already indicated we could have it at his pharmacy (where i also practice). So if we do a news conference we have a venue. It is right across the street from kstp ch 5, so that can't hurt. If so, would Wed July 8th be ok ?
i put some feelers out for speakers, and we could use more. Let me know.
The framing, messaging, and talking points would be our bread and butter: HC as a public good, single-payer medicare for all, a public option on OUR terms, and also, and this is important, a state single-payer option ( any state that opts for single-payer can do so). a state single-payer option may be a way of getting single-payer in the debate through the back door, window, or chimney. the state single- payer option was actually introduced early in 1993 as part of the national debate, but quickly scuttled.
So pls give me feedback as to whether folks are down with this , or not.
Also, if you can do any tabling at the Pride Festival for UHCAN-MN this weekend, let me know as soon as possible.
MPR propaganda on the health care system is not good. Yesterday, in a
solitation for comment, the "public" radio station asked listeners to share
their views of a "government run" health care system. As any informed person
knows, the issue is not whether or not to have government run health care. The
issue is whether or not to have government funded health insurance for everyone,
including all those that already receive it through Medicare, Medicaid and the
VA.
Real public radio looks like this:
http://blip.tv/file/2244275
--- In uhcan-mn@yahoogroups.com, "Amy M. Johnston" <amjohnston1001@...> wrote:
>
> Fill out this survey from MPR. I don't have employer-based healthcare
> coverage, but I used to, so that's enough for me to answer the survey. :-)
>
> -------- Original Message --------
> Subject: Rate your health care coverage
> Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2009 06:31:20 -0700
> From: Minnesota Public Radio <publicinsight@...>
> Reply-To: publicinsight@...
>
>
>
> >
> > View web version
> >
<http://www.elabs7.com/c.html?rtr=on&s=av19,gyjz,kr,5560,a9d5,2h63,5qoe&MLM_MID=\
791279&MLM_MLID=747&MLM_SITEID=506781&MLM_UNIQUEID=1c36b4164e>
> > | Send this message to a friend
> >
<http://elabs7.com/content/506781/forward_mpr.html?sender=amyjohnston@...&uid=1c\
36b4164e&p=10593&mid=791279>
> >
> >
> > Public Insight Network
> > <http://www.elabs7.com/c.html?rtr=on&s=av19,gyjz,kr,lad9,2g08,2h63,5qoe>
> >
> > *What's happening with your health benefits?*
> >
> > U.S. health insurers say a public health insurance option
> > <http://www.elabs7.com/c.html?rtr=on&s=av19,gyjz,kr,ljac,gqv4,2h63,5qoe>
> > would "dismantle employer-based coverage." President Obama says a
> > government plan
> > <http://www.elabs7.com/c.html?rtr=on&s=av19,gyjz,kr,h7pt,jjei,2h63,5qoe>
> > could discipline health companies into being competitive.
> >
> > Help Minnesota Public Radio news move beyond the rhetoric and report
> > on what you�re seeing.
> >
> > What has your health coverage changed? How have you coped with rising
> > premiums? * Give us your insights by answering a few questions.
> > <http://www.elabs7.com/c.html?rtr=on&s=av19,gyjz,kr,kly3,e5vf,2h63,5qoe>*
> >
> > And please pass this note to others willing to share their experience
> > with employer-based health insurance.
> >
> >
> > All the best,
> >
> > Michael Caputo
> > Analyst, Public Insight Journalism
> > Minnesota Public Radio News
> > (651) 290-1081
> > mcaputo@...
> >
> > *What is the Public Insight Network?*
> > The Public Insight Network is you and thousands of others like you who
> > have agreed to share what they know to help public radio cover the
> > news, find stories, and add depth to our reporting.
> >
> > As part of the Public Insight Network, you have an open line into our
> > newsroom and programs. We'll send you about an e-mail a month asking
> > for your knowledge on issues and stories we are pursuing.
> >
> >
> >
> >
>
And please pass this note to others willing to share their experience
with employer-based health insurance.
All the best,
Michael Caputo
Analyst, Public Insight Journalism
Minnesota Public Radio News
(651) 290-1081 mcaputo@...
What is the Public Insight Network?
The Public Insight Network is you and thousands of others like you who
have agreed to share what they know to help public radio cover the
news, find stories, and add depth to our reporting.
As part of the Public Insight Network, you have
an open line into our newsroom and programs. We'll send you about an
e-mail a month asking for your knowledge on issues and stories we are
pursuing.
across from a televison station: good! (abc just took a stand by doing special coverage on the issue; ceo publicly pushed back against the conservative echo chamber and its logorrhea.)
a pharmacist speaker - trusted and respected profession: good!
a nurse - most trusted profession in u.s.a.: good! some good nurse speakers at the capitol rally 5 january.
a family deeply affected by profit-making h.c. industry, including a male to 'speak to' the predominately male gatekeepers on this issue: good! people end up in wheelchairs and on gurneys (and worse) with current heartless system. let's show the results.
a couple businesspersons, male and female, to the point of value for american business.
definitely give time to a minnesota single-payer option. give a boost to politicians willing to lead on this issue.
schedule at 5 o'clock for live coverage. get some visuals with signs and movement. lab coats, nurses uniforms, suits and business wear. good!
it's on my calendar; announce time and place details.
To: uhcan-mn@yahoogroups.com From: joel@... Date: Wed, 24 Jun 2009 14:19:56 -0500 Subject: [uhcan-mn] proposal to hold news conference
Hi Everyone,
the drive for health care reform is about as scorching as the weather. So to build on it, and follow-up on the great coverage we got post single-payer rally at the big HMO, in the Star Tribune (almost unheard of on the front page of the business section), i would like to suggest that we strike again while the fire's hot in the form of a news conference.
Tom Sengupta, from Schneider Drug Store has already indicated we could have it at his pharmacy (where i also practice). So if we do a news conference we have a venue. It is right across the street from kstp ch 5, so that can't hurt. If so, would Wed July 8th be ok ?
i put some feelers out for speakers, and we could use more. Let me know.
The framing, messaging, and talking points would be our bread and butter: HC as a public good, single-payer medicare for all, a public option on OUR terms, and also, and this is important, a state single-payer option ( any state that opts for single-payer can do so). a state single-payer option may be a way of getting single-payer in the debate through the back door, window, or chimney. the state single- payer option was actually introduced early in 1993 as part of the national debate, but quickly scuttled.
So pls give me feedback as to whether folks are down with this , or not.
Also, if you can do any tabling at the Pride Festival for UHCAN-MN this weekend, let me know as soon as possible.
Let's have some healthy skepticism. I suspect Minnesota Purchased Radio of providing information to our opposition--this might be the profitteers' indirect method of opposition research at minimal cost. Never underestimate the means employed by a profit-seeking entity to get what it wants. The reporters involved may be unwitting handmaids gathering info which can be used against our side.
Not an MPR member due to the lack of "public" in its policy,
Diane J. Peterson White Bear Lake, Minnesota birch7@...
And please pass this note to others willing to share their experience with employer-based health insurance.
All the best,
Michael Caputo Analyst, Public Insight Journalism Minnesota Public Radio News (651) 290-1081 mcaputo@mpr.org
What is the Public Insight Network? The Public Insight Network is you and thousands of others like you who have agreed to share what they know to help public radio cover the news, find stories, and add depth to our reporting.
As part of the Public Insight Network, you have an open line into our newsroom and programs. We'll send you about an e-mail a month asking for your knowledge on issues and stories we are pursuing.
No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 8.5.375 / Virus Database: 270.12.91/2201 - Release Date: 06/25/09 06:22:00
the drive for health care reform is about as scorching as the weather. So to build on it, and follow-up on the great coverage we got post single-payer rally at the big HMO, in the Star Tribune (almost unheard of on the front page of the business section), i would like to suggest that we strike again while the fire's hot in the form of a news conference.
Tom Sengupta, from Schneider Drug Store has already indicated we could have it at his pharmacy (where i also practice). So if we do a news conference we have a venue. It is right across the street from kstp ch 5, so that can't hurt. If so, would Wed July 8th be ok ?
i put some feelers out for speakers, and we could use more. Let me know.
The framing, messaging, and talking points would be our bread and butter: HC as a public good, single-payer medicare for all, a public option on OUR terms, and also, and this is important, a state single-payer option ( any state that opts for single-payer can do so). a state single-payer option may be a way of getting single-payer in the debate through the back door, window, or chimney. the state single- payer option was actually introduced early in 1993 as part of the national debate, but quickly scuttled.
So pls give me feedback as to whether folks are down with this , or not.
Also, if you can do any tabling at the Pride Festival for UHCAN-MN this weekend, let me know as soon as possible.
Summery St. Paul Neighborhood Network (SPNN) viewers:
"Our World In Depth" cablecasts on SPNN Channel 15 on Tuesdays at 5pm,
midnight and Wednesday mornings at 10am, after DemocracyNow! All
households with basic cable may watch.
** Tomorrow/Tues, 6/23, 5pm & midnight and Wed, 6/24, 10am **
Ramona Africa from the Haile Q. Brown Center
in 1985, the Philadelphia police department dropped a bomb on the home of
Ramona Africa's family massacring 11. Ramona, a member of the MOVE
organization, was the sole adult survivor of the incident. Ramona talks
more about MOVE, and critiques "the system". filmed in St. Paul in April
2009. note: due to a previous scheduling error, this show is repeated :)
** Tues, 6/30, 5pm & midnight and Wed, 7/1, 10am **
Single Payer: HELL YEAH!
longtime Twin Cities nurse and single-payer health care advocate Faith
Kidder and DFL Progressive Caucus chair Dan Brown share their insights on,
and passion for, single-payer universal health care. hosted by Eric Angell.
________________________________________________________________
Meandering Minneapolis Television Network (MTN) viewers:
"Our World In Depth" cablecasts on MTN Channel 17 on Saturdays at 9pm and
Tuesdays at 8am, after DemocracyNow! Households with basic cable may
watch.
** Sat., 6/27, 9pm and Tues, 6/30, 8am **
Single Payer: HELL YEAH!
longtime Twin Cities nurse and single-payer health care advocate Faith
Kidder and DFL Progressive Caucus chair Dan Brown share their insights on,
and passion for, single-payer universal health care. hosted by Eric Angell.
____________________________________
stream it: www.ourworldindepth.org
____________________________________
"Our World In Depth" features analysis of public affairs with
consideration of and participation from Twin Cities area activists.
Locally produced and not corporately influenced, "Our World In Depth" may
be better than PBS! Order a dvd copy or contact us at
ourworldindepth@....
Hi All,
I'm really excited about Pride Festival and i view our booth as fun
and a bit of a party. The theme this yr seems to be "Our Rights, Your
Rights, Human Rights". So single-payer HC as a human right fits in
well. It would also be great if anyone on this list from a GLBT group
could network with us, or other ideas ?
For those who may be able to Table let me know when you can table
(see below). (Dori will simultaneously be do Comm work for North Star
Health Collective medics on the Dyke March). I dont have the booth
assignment/location yet, but will let everyone know as soon as i do.
If you are not on the list below, feel free to let me know if you
want to table. We also need a few cheerleaders for the parade to do
"HMOs are jive Talkin" and "HMO U Ugly". So let me know if you can do
that.
In addition to our exhibit board, and usual lit. i have some GLBT
info and HC. A flyer on the current debate, and actions people can
take, including national/state single-payer bills, but also direct
actions, and the Prairie HEALTH Companions Fund, which i will send
out soon. Go to www.tc.pride.org for festival info. Also on hand,
some health screening tests for those who want to do them, and single-
payer t-shirts for sale. Obviously we can alternate walking around,
enjoying the other booths, music, food, drag shows.
I have the 10 x 10 pop-up tent. i still have to look-up our booth
assignment. Anyone who helps set-up the booth on friday at 11:30am
can attend the catered reception at the Women's Club next to Loring
Park. So come for the food and stay for the conversation.
The Festival hrs are sat june 27 10am to 1opm
and sun june 28th 10am-5pm
so that's when we need folks to table.
Carol Halonen: sun 1-4.
Joel albers: sat 10a-12:30p and 6:30p-10pm, sun 1p-5p
Harry Greenberg:
Zev Aeloney:
Dori Ullman
Beth Shapiro:
Excuse me for what might be considered spamming your list, but if you are interested in discussing health care and other issues of US politics and policy, a new E-Democracy.org forum is starting up:
E-Democracy.org forums are different than most blogs and listservs in that there is no moderation, save that from members of their own posts, that necessary for verifying identities (no anonymity is permitted), or for purposes of enforcing the rules that all members agree to abide by in joining. So far, there are only forums from the neighborhood, city, to state level, and this national level issues forum is somewhat of an experiment in the larger e-democracy.org experiment that only starts when we have a hundred members registered; we're a dirty dozen short of starting.
Thanks,
Bill Kahn, Minneapolis
Unemployed and figuring out how to pay my next bimonthly health insurance premium to one of "the big four," re-introduced to UHCAN at a neighborhood celebration a few weeks back.
I'm picking up the 10 x 10 pop-up tent today. Set-up day is this
friday the 26th, and anyone who tables can attend the reception at
the Women's Club across from Loring Park hosted by Quorum, TC GLBT
Chamber of commerce, and TC Pride. I have to RSVP by June 22, so let
me know soon.
thanks,
joel
Health Care is a Human Right – Urge the Senate to Have a Real Debate on Single Payer
We at Amnesty International believe that policymakers have a historic opportunity to reform a broken health care system. During the presidential debates, Barack Obama took a step in the right direction by affirming that health care should be a right. The legislation now emerging from Washington is, however, a long way from fulfilling that vision.
One reason the current draft legislation falls short of the mark is that single-payer advocates, a crucial human rights constituency, have been largely excluded from the reform process. While the human right to health care does not mandate any particular type of health care system, of the reform proposals being discussed in the U.S. today, the single-payer plans are more universal, equitable and accountable – the three key principles of the human right to health care. Single-payer plans approach health care as an essential service and a public good. A single-payer health care system would pair private delivery with public financing – that is, with private doctors, clinics and hospitals getting all their reimbursement from the government. Medicare, a well-established and popular part of our current health care system, works this way; a single-payer system would institute an improved Medicare for all.
Two of Amnesty International's ally organizations, the National Economic and Social Rights Initiative and the National Health Law Program, have analyzed current single-payer proposals, and found them to come much closer to fulfilling the human right to health care than the market-based reform plans.
But the powerful Senate Finance Committee, the single most important legislative grouping in the reform process, has yet to hold a public hearing on single-payer. In fact, the committee chair, Sen. Max Baucus, has said that single-payer is "off the table" – a stance he has since acknowledged was mistaken.
Publicly financed and administered health care should be expanded as the strongest vehicle for making health care universally accessible and accountable. Single-payer is a crucial proposal for fulfilling the human right to health care. Without a single-payer seat at the table, we risk that no one will speak up for true universality and a fair, equitable health care system.
Too much of the current debate about health care assumes that we can talk about health care in the same way that we talk about consumer products. But health care is not about markets; it is about the right of every person to
live a life of dignity. In health care reform, human rights must come first.
Though things are moving very fast in Congress, it's not too late to make your voice heard. Tell Max Baucus that single-payer advocates must be heard!
Sincerely, Sameer Dossani Demand Dignity Campaign Director Amnesty International, USA
P.S. You can always get more information on Amnesty International's Healthcare Is A Human Right project and sign our petition at http://www.amnestyusa.org/healthcare
Anja Rudiger Human Right to Health Program Director National Economic and Social Rights Initiative/ National Health Law Program 90 John Street, Ste. 308 New York, NY 10038 tel 212.253.1710 ext. 305, fax 212.385.6124 www.nesri.org The Human Right to Health Program, run jointly by NESRI and NHeLP, is developing human rights tools to support community organizations and coalitions across the U.S. in their efforts to achieve rights-based health care reform at the local, state, and federal level. Subscribe to the Human Right to Health listserv:
The "public option" is so repugnant to republicans and centrist democrats that they have resorted to reviving a previously invalidated insurance scheme which they call "cooperative" health insurance purchasers as an attempt to thwart the "public option". Altho there are few details, it resembles the managed competition model or some version of it, advanced by Clinton in 1994, yet without evidence of controlling costs or improving quality of care.
In a nutshell, managed competition legislation would allow the formation of a few large purchasers of health insurance to stimulate competition among HMOs to lower premium prices. Problem is HMO and other managed care insurers are already so monopolistic they can't compete with themselves. In MN, e.g. the vast majority of the 5 million population are enrolled into one of four HMOs: Blue Cross, Medica (adm by United Health Group), HealthPartners, and Preferred One. So rather than compete for the biggest slice of the pie, HMOs can tacitly collude (they are all represented by the same trade assoc. Mn council of Health Plans) and enlarge the pie of health care dollars (and profit) rather than compete for the biggest piece.
Managed competition theory was advanced by Alain Enthoven (Stanford business school professor) and Richard Kronick who published in New England Journal of Medicine in 1989, "A consumer-choice health plan for the 1990s." Kronick subsequently in 1993 had the integrity to publish a follow-up article in NEJM invalidating his own managed competition theory, "The marketplace in health care reform: the demographic limitations of managed competition N Engl J Med 1993;328:148-152.
Max Baucus and the Senate finance Committee are doing a dishonest disservice to the American people by trying to rehash a previously invalidated approach to HC reform in the face of a crisis.
Medicare: Made in America – DC Lobby Day and Rally
July, 30th, 2009, Washington, DC
Celebrate
Medicare's 44th Birthday by showing Congress and President Obama the
people, unions, doctors, nurses, seniors, faith groups, and Americans
of every stripe support a single-payer system.
As President Obama says, "We must build on what works and leave out what doesn't." Medicare has
successfully provided care to seniors and people with disabilities for
almost half a century. Medicare is a truly American-made system that
other health care systems around the world have since been modeled
after. With little over 3% administrative overhead, we must look to
this American solution to our health care crisis.
The best way to save this system is to expand it and make it a truly single-payer system by removing the for-profit interests.
Polls consistently show that the public supports a Medicare for All
system, and 59% of physicians support it. In the face of inadequate
reform to our health care system, we want Congress to make sure our
voice is heard.
The Leadership Conference for Guaranteed Health Care is launching a
rally and lobby day on Thursday, July 30th in Washington DC with
concurrent actions around the country to bring this message to
Washington DC and the Congress.
The Rally and Lobby Day in DC are currently being planned and logistics will be announced soon.
We urge you and your organization to help support this important action in any of the following ways:
1) Cosponsor the event in DC by providing a donation to the effort
or providing buses and/or accommodations for your members or supporters
to join us for the day. Please complete the cosponsorship form below.
2) Provide a speaker for the rally planned in Washington DC.
3) Personally deliver a message to your Members of Congress on July
30th in DC and/or in the home district of your Representatives that you
support expanding and improving Medicare for All.
4) Join the planning committee of this event to add support to the many things that must be done in preparation.
5) Donate to help fund the rally. Send checks to California Nurses
Association National Nurses Organizing Committee, National Nurses
Organizing Committee 888 16th St NW Suite 640 Washington, DC 20006,
memo: July 30th
We look forward to hearing from you soon about how you would like to get involved!
I am all in favour of the single payer system,.
Why do we need to reinvent the wheel and come up with a new sysytem.
Lets make a phone call to Ottawa, and adapt the Canadian health care system.
Assuming the numbers are correct, we can insure all americans for about 1.5
trillion dollars a year, or under $6000 dollars a person(these numbers are
based on the cost that Canada pays for their health care)
Now I know their are problems with the Canadain system one of them being,
that becuase its completely free, their are some abuses to it. But many people
believe that this can be reduced by having a co-pay.
Second. Do not believe those who says that depending on your age you might
not get care. If that was the cases, why is the Canadain government spening
,money to keep my grandmother who has Alzhimers alive.
Third, Yes their are lines in Canada and a waiting list. But at least you get
the option to stand in line. Of course their are no lines in the United States,
Why should their be, if you know your not going to get the care, why bother
waiting in line.
Fourth, almost no one in Canada desires the american System
but I can tell you many people would love to have the Canadian system
Fifth. Doctors in Canada spend time with you and will go out of the way. When
my mother fainted at home, The doctor maade a house call. When is the last
time that a Doctor in the USA made a house call. My wife tells me it does not
happan.
Thank You
Marc
Hi Everyone,
The Pride Festival UHCAN-MN is registered for is fast approaching
saturday and sunday, june 27 and 28th, 10am-10pm and 10am-5pm, If you
are available to do some tabling during these hours, especially
saturday from 1-6, your help would be very appreciated. It will be
fun, and you willhave plenty of time to enjoy the festival if we can
have at least one person at the booth. UHCAN-MN has all the resources
needed like literature, talking points, and health screenings for
those interested in that. There will also be a free reception with
food and drink on friday afternoon after set-up.
One thing we dont yet have, but need, is a 10 x 10 booth, or canopy,
like for camping or what not.
If anyone knows of one we can borrow,pls let me know asap.
thanks,
joel
Single-payer is so popular now that Congress spends much of their time trying to explain it away. But it’s not going anywhere, and we demand congressional hearings and democracy. The SP “Medicare for All” movement is gaining momentum and constantly in the media now thanks to recent direct actions of SP advocates who “sat-in” on the Senate Finance Committee deliberations, despite being segregated from the insurance, drug, and device industry insider guest-list. We will continue the American tradition of “sit-ins” for our health care civil rights and a diversity of other direct actions. Altho we don’t have a vote or a seat, ultimately Congress will have to listen to the voices of the people in the street. Keep your eyes on the single-payer prize, hold on.
I agree with what everyone else has said and would also clearly point out
the "personal" financial interests that 30 key lawmakers responsible for
drafting policy related to the healthcare crisis have in the healthcare
industry. See Monday's democracynow! episode as well as the original
washington post article for more details. We all know very well that health
insurance companies have a heavy corporate lobby hand in our congress and
is primarily concerned with profit. Just look at the recent report
uncovering the investments that insurance companies have in the tobacco
industry. It doesn't take a genius to come to the conclusion that profit is
the only driver of these companies. Why is the US the only industrialized
(or post-industrialized I would say) country that doesn't have some form of
a single payer system, especially when the majority of people, and the
majority of doctors want it? We cannot be pacified by half-measures. We
need real investment in healthcare in this country for the people and by
the people. We need to train our own physicians instead of stealing them
from developing countries, we need to build an infrastructure that is
accessible and available equally to every one, and we need to cut out the
profiteering beauocracy and middlemen. A public option is not a real option
if what we are actually concerned with is securing healthcare for all. With
a public option, I envision America's healthcare system as multi-tiered
with the top of the tier receiving advanced life-saving treatments and
diagnostics from the very best physicians at a high and private cost while
the poor are left with inadequately funded public health insurance
providing at best basic measures, less access to life-saving treatments
from overly strained physicians. The healthcare system in America is a
global issue and reform starts right here. Props to the baucus 13. But the
fight doesn't end there. Getting our voices heard is not enough to pacify
us. And neither would be the provision of mandated buy-in to substandard
and insufficient public health insurance. The people running this country
need to open their ears and their minds to REAL CHANGE, 'cause this just
isn't working. We need to stop investing in a system that obviously doesn't
work.
Peace ya'll,
Rebecca
On Jun 16 2009, Andra Fjone wrote:
>Joel,
>
>Thanks. My daughter is a high school English teacher. She and her education
>colleagues characterize Obama's plan for reforming the education system as
>"Bush light". Disappointingly, his health care reform plan smacks of the
>same.
>
>Andra Fjone
>
>
>
> _____
>
>From: uhcan-mn@yahoogroups.com [mailto:uhcan-mn@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf
>Of Joel Albers
>Sent: Monday, June 15, 2009 1:31 PM
>To: uhcan-mn@yahoogroups.com
>Subject: [uhcan-mn] single-payer v. public option
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>Interested in your views of whether progressives should advocate for
>single-payer "Medicare for All" and/or the Obama's individual mandate
>for individuals, small businesses, and self-employed to buy private
>coverage with a Medicare buy-in option, that is, the Medicare buy-in
>option.
>
>Myself, Carol, and Beth had an impromptu discussion on this and came
>up with the following as a cpourse of action for UHCAN-MN and
>advancing a progressive framwork for debate. i will show cost
>estimates later. To summarize, SP is gaining much traction through
>direct action, and we should continue this, and demand Congressional
>hearings on single-payer, and other forms of real democracy, perhaps
>form our own Commission etc. Direct Action has helped galvanize the
>media to report on SP. By not keeping our eyes on the prize, and
>only advocate for the "public option", could seriously divide this
>movement. Also, by advocating "Medicare for All", it is understood
>that the Medicare public option would be the fallback position. Tom
>at Schneider drug where i work and i were discussing putting together
>a flyer, possible press release, and press conference on this since
>it is all over the media right now, and in the public eye.
>
>thanks,
>joel
>
>
>
>
Reminder that my Health Care System Overview course offered through Experimental College starts this Thursday--you can register even after course starts.
A new course called "Health Care System Overview"is being offered through Experimental College this summer, starting on June 18th, Thursday. The facilitaror is John Schwarz.
A basic summary is given in the abbreviated description below from the Course Catalogue.
A seminar that serves as an introduction to the current US health system, basic health economics theory, European systems, and reform proposals. Special emphasis on public systems—single-payer and its variations. A look at the single-payer movement’s strategies and suggested reforms. This course doesn'taddress medical issues.It will give the student a solid understanding of health care financing and coverage/access systems. Thereare no required readings or assignments.
Location is 155 Ford Hall on U of M - East Bank campus.
Start date is June 18 through July 16. Five Thursdays.
Meeting time is 6:30 pm to 8:30 pm.
Length of course is 1x/week for 5 weeks.
The EXCO site has the full description of the course with a full outline of material to be covered. It's comprehensive and in-depth for those seeking that, but can be enjoyed at a more general level for those interested in that sort of thing.
I have been a very active single-payer advocate for the past 5 years, often working with health care legislative matters. I've testified at the legislature 14 times in the past few years about health care issues. I was a member of the Legislature's Single-Payer Working Group in 2007 and was lead author of its final report. My work has centered around research, analysis, and educating the public about health systems. I have been a member of or associated with a number of the largest single-payer/universal and other progressive health reform advocacy organizations; I list my health policy related experience in more detail on EXCO in the full course description. I have an MA in Government from Cornell where my research focus was health systems. I taught a version of this course in 2006.
Please sign-up and/or send this information to anyone you think might be interested or relevant listserve. Please contact me for further information and with comments, questions, and suggestions.
John M. Schwarz
(651) 442-8899
john@... (A progressive health reform organization, not associated with the United HealthGroup HMO.)
Thanks. My daughter is a high school
English teacher. She and her education colleagues characterize Obama’s
plan for reforming the education system as “Bush light”. Disappointingly,
his health care reform plan smacks of the same.
Andra Fjone
From:
uhcan-mn@yahoogroups.com [mailto:uhcan-mn@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of Joel Albers Sent: Monday, June 15, 2009 1:31
PM To: uhcan-mn@yahoogroups.com Subject: [uhcan-mn] single-payer
v. public option
Interested in your views of whether progressives
should advocate for
single-payer "Medicare for All" and/or the Obama's individual mandate
for individuals, small businesses, and self-employed to buy private
coverage with a Medicare buy-in option, that is, the Medicare buy-in
option.
Myself, Carol, and Beth had an impromptu discussion on this and came
up with the following as a cpourse of action for UHCAN-MN and
advancing a progressive framwork for debate. i will show cost
estimates later. To summarize, SP is gaining much traction through
direct action, and we should continue this, and demand Congressional
hearings on single-payer, and other forms of real democracy, perhaps
form our own Commission etc. Direct Action has helped galvanize the
media to report on SP. By not keeping our eyes on the prize, and
only advocate for the "public option", could seriously divide this
movement. Also, by advocating "Medicare for All", it is understood
that the Medicare public option would be the fallback position. Tom
at Schneider drug where i work and i were discussing putting together
a flyer, possible press release, and press conference on this since
it is all over the media right now, and in the public eye.
and one more reason to stay Single Payer focused -- my health insurance has been paid for my entire life, I'm fairly old and have always been healthy. I should have a good little nest egg of health insurance dollars for my old age, but I don't -- I have zero if I loose my job. Health insurance is hands down the worst financial investment anyone can make. For this reason, I do not support Obama's mandated health insurance. If it can be law that we have to purchase health insurance, then I saw let's make it a law that anyone with high cholestorol has to by Cherrios -- after all, my retirement is tied up with the financial health of the Cherrios business :) and by the way, what happened to this argument. A while ago there was talk that health insurance would no longer be tied to one's job, that we would keep it and carry it with us from job to job, etc.
Just another point how the insurance industry is profiting off the american public without delivering much worth in return. I call them "financial terrorists" or corporations who are destroying the fabric of the nation.
On Mon, Jun 15, 2009 at 10:29 PM, Joel Albers <joel@...> wrote:
We had 6 responses to the question of whether to advocate for single-payer v. the "public option' within Obama's individual mandate plan. all 6 were for single-payer. i put them in a string below. that adds to Carol, Beth and myself. the list serve is still open for more responses, but i will put together a flyer/press release to post for comments/edits for a uhcan-mn press conference we can have at Schneider Drug, across the street from kstp on University ave.
Direct Action
Single payer
Expose the Obama option as the corporate sham that it is.
I know, you all are shocked that I take this position.
//:-)>-------
Michael Cavlan RN
Amen to that!
Barbara
---------------------------------------
Obama has said over and over that "we will keep the programs that work and get rid of those that don't" The more we are out there doing our direct actions and presenting Single Payer as a proven cost-effective way to go - the more opportunities we have to illustrate to the rest of America why the private insurance system "doesn't work". And that should continue to be our primary talking point - it is the addition of a "private insurance middle man" that adds costs and takes away coverage.
There is such clarity about this that we should not allow the fear of division to get in the way. (The challenge is to keep our forces mobilized and enthusiastic: we need to keep reminding ourselves that we really do have the power and that the corporatists are running scared. There is so much more to be done to fix our broken global economy - and getting the point across that everywhere else in the developed world, healthcare is a right and a single publicly managed insurance pool progressively funded makes it work. We are loosing out to global competitors because of this.
We get to compromise on short term tactics - but not on long term strategic goals - especially when we are so far along on this path and winning over more allies every day. So long as we keep up the debate and get the information out there - more and more Americans become educated enough to cross over that threshold and join us in holding out for a healthcare system free of the infectious virus of private health insurance.
We should probably start using the pathology model more and more. There is a period in the rise of an epidemic when the exact cause is still unknown and all sorts of ineffective solutions are offered as "cures". But once the etiology of the epidemic is understood then there is no reason to keep trying methods that don't focus directly on stopping the spread of the pathogen and mitigating against the pathology itself.
Part of what we have to do in inspiring our troops is to keep using Apollo program metaphors - ones that set a clear goals with attainable landmarks (as to how we rid the system of the pathology). Let's use our medical expertise and take the metaphor of the "pathology of private health insurance" or the "for profit virus" and use it as a way of teaching the value of a "virus free" funding environment for health care. The more we do that - outline a plan to move us in stages away from any for-profit decision making in the big insurance picture - the more we get our troops expecting the next step and the next - and it's much harder for the opposition to stop the movement until it has reached a place of real paradigm shift.
If we see the "public option" as a possible transition phase - then we need to show why and how it is just a phase (and not a long term compromise) the next step in eradicating ("oops - another epidemiological metaphor ! Why how did that come up?!") the parasitic ("oops - yet another") private insurance middle men.
When one is running a race - especially as the goal gets in sight - it is absolutely essential that one aim for a point or places well beyond the finish line - in order to finish strong and with the kind of follow-through that allows for winning well and big! We should be talking about the benefits of an economy in which American employers are no longer burdened by picking up the tab and workers and entrepreneurs are free to exercise their skills and creativity because they know they don't have to worry any more about private insurance premiums and can imagine a bankruptcy-free future! [There are some delicious opportunities for wonderfully positive framing of a healthy - 'parasite free' - healthcare system.]
-in Love and Peace,
-Demi Miller
-------------------------------------
we're advocates.we're not politicians. we should not compromise our position based on what the politicians say or intimate is 'doable.' it's their job to cut deals, our job to hold our position. if we don't show resolve, they won't do it for us.
if we're going to get the 'overton window' on the political spectrum shifting in a progressive direction, we need to, first, be clear and firm about what we want, and then, second, frame our issues in ways that resonate with stake-holders, the general public, and the media.
issue advocacy is not about compromising a primo or anticipating the comfort zone of liberals. again, we're not deal-brokers or insiders. if we, as advocates, don't stand firm, why should they? and if we don't cave, yet they do, then we elect new politicians. maintaining our policy position is hardly militant, radical stuff (this isn't, e.g., nonviolent direct action which may have, as it were, 'gotten the donkey's attention').
in a time when the conservative point of view is sensed, if not fully understood, to be bankrupt, yet the progressive agenda is incoherent and defensive, we need to offer efficient, effective alternatives to the mess we're in and be consistent about them. if we hesitate, who will trust us? we can't build momentum back-pedaling.
phill
-----------------------------------------------
Joel and other hard workers - First, thanks for all the hard work! The plan that President Obama is supporting now (but one could hope that his eyes will be opened soon) assures that the insurance industry continues the control of the health care dollar. Also, does anyone really know just how the general public feels about their current health insurance company or coverage? If a company offers health insurance as a benefit it probably will be the one with the highest upfront costs to the employee (in other words the cheapest option available) and the employer paying a small amount of the premium. I do not believe that most people even know what their health care plan covers until an event occurs in their or one of their family 's lives. By then it is usually too late and the person is in bankruptcy court when they express remorse for the decisions that they made about health insurance "coverage". I still do not know where President Obama gets his information. I thought that he was wiser than he appears to be, especially on the issue of health care reform. You are right - we need to show that a large number of people want a single payer plan, they just listen to too much of the garbage put out by the health insurers themselves. (Would one believe that the "information" put out by the health insurance companies is thoroughly researched?)
If we think that single payer is really what we want, we should continue to advocate for it. For one thing, it makes Medicare for all look more centrist.
We had 6 responses to the question of whether to advocate for single-payer v. the "public option' within Obama's individual mandate plan. all 6 were for single-payer. i put them in a string below. that adds to Carol, Beth and myself. the list serve is still open for more responses, but i will put together a flyer/press release to post for comments/edits for a uhcan-mn press conference we can have at Schneider Drug, across the street from kstp on University ave.
Direct Action
Single payer
Expose the Obama option as the corporate sham that it is.
I know, you all are shocked that I take this position.
//:-)>-------
Michael Cavlan RN
Amen to that!
Barbara
---------------------------------------
Obama has said over and over that "we will keep the programs that work and get rid of those that don't" The more we are out there doing our direct actions and presenting Single Payer as a proven cost-effective way to go - the more opportunities we have to illustrate to the rest of America why the private insurance system "doesn't work". And that should continue to be our primary talking point - it is the addition of a "private insurance middle man" that adds costs and takes away coverage.
There is such clarity about this that we should not allow the fear of division to get in the way. (The challenge is to keep our forces mobilized and enthusiastic: we need to keep reminding ourselves that we really do have the power and that the corporatists are running scared. There is so much more to be done to fix our broken global economy - and getting the point across that everywhere else in the developed world, healthcare is a right and a single publicly managed insurance pool progressively funded makes it work. We are loosing out to global competitors because of this.
We get to compromise on short term tactics - but not on long term strategic goals - especially when we are so far along on this path and winning over more allies every day. So long as we keep up the debate and get the information out there - more and more Americans become educated enough to cross over that threshold and join us in holding out for a healthcare system free of the infectious virus of private health insurance.
We should probably start using the pathology model more and more. There is a period in the rise of an epidemic when the exact cause is still unknown and all sorts of ineffective solutions are offered as "cures". But once the etiology of the epidemic is understood then there is no reason to keep trying methods that don't focus directly on stopping the spread of the pathogen and mitigating against the pathology itself.
Part of what we have to do in inspiring our troops is to keep using Apollo program metaphors - ones that set a clear goals with attainable landmarks (as to how we rid the system of the pathology). Let's use our medical expertise and take the metaphor of the "pathology of private health insurance" or the "for profit virus" and use it as a way of teaching the value of a "virus free" funding environment for health care. The more we do that - outline a plan to move us in stages away from any for-profit decision making in the big insurance picture - the more we get our troops expecting the next step and the next - and it's much harder for the opposition to stop the movement until it has reached a place of real paradigm shift.
If we see the "public option" as a possible transition phase - then we need to show why and how it is just a phase (and not a long term compromise) the next step in eradicating ("oops - another epidemiological metaphor ! Why how did that come up?!") the parasitic ("oops - yet another") private insurance middle men.
When one is running a race - especially as the goal gets in sight - it is absolutely essential that one aim for a point or places well beyond the finish line - in order to finish strong and with the kind of follow-through that allows for winning well and big! We should be talking about the benefits of an economy in which American employers are no longer burdened by picking up the tab and workers and entrepreneurs are free to exercise their skills and creativity because they know they don't have to worry any more about private insurance premiums and can imagine a bankruptcy-free future! [There are some delicious opportunities for wonderfully positive framing of a healthy - 'parasite free' - healthcare system.]
-in Love and Peace,
-Demi Miller
-------------------------------------
we're advocates.we're not politicians. we should not compromise our position based on what the politicians say or intimate is 'doable.' it's their job to cut deals, our job to hold our position. if we don't show resolve, they won't do it for us.
if we're going to get the 'overton window' on the political spectrum shifting in a progressive direction, we need to, first, be clear and firm about what we want, and then, second, frame our issues in ways that resonate with stake-holders, the general public, and the media.
issue advocacy is not about compromising a primo or anticipating the comfort zone of liberals. again, we're not deal-brokers or insiders. if we, as advocates, don't stand firm, why should they? and if we don't cave, yet they do, then we elect new politicians. maintaining our policy position is hardly militant, radical stuff (this isn't, e.g., nonviolent direct action which may have, as it were, 'gotten the donkey's attention').
in a time when the conservative point of view is sensed, if not fully understood, to be bankrupt, yet the progressive agenda is incoherent and defensive, we need to offer efficient, effective alternatives to the mess we're in and be consistent about them. if we hesitate, who will trust us? we can't build momentum back-pedaling.
phill
-----------------------------------------------
Joel and other hard workers - First, thanks for all the hard work! The plan that President Obama is supporting now (but one could hope that his eyes will be opened soon) assures that the insurance industry continues the control of the health care dollar. Also, does anyone really know just how the general public feels about their current health insurance company or coverage? If a company offers health insurance as a benefit it probably will be the one with the highest upfront costs to the employee (in other words the cheapest option available) and the employer paying a small amount of the premium. I do not believe that most people even know what their health care plan covers until an event occurs in their or one of their family 's lives. By then it is usually too late and the person is in bankruptcy court when they express remorse for the decisions that they made about health insurance "coverage". I still do not know where President Obama gets his information. I thought that he was wiser than he appears to be, especially on the issue of health care reform. You are right - we need to show that a large number of people want a single payer plan, they just listen to too much of the garbage put out by the health insurers themselves. (Would one believe that the "information" put out by the health insurance companies is thoroughly researched?)
If we think that single payer is really what we want, we should continue to advocate for it. For one thing, it makes Medicare for all look more centrist.
Interested in your views of whether progressives should advocate for
single-payer "Medicare for All" and/or the Obama's individual mandate
for individuals, small businesses, and self-employed to buy private
coverage with a Medicare buy-in option, that is, the Medicare buy-in
option.
Myself, Carol, and Beth had an impromptu discussion on this and came
up with the following as a cpourse of action for UHCAN-MN and
advancing a progressive framwork for debate. i will show cost
estimates later. To summarize, SP is gaining much traction through
direct action, and we should continue this, and demand Congressional
hearings on single-payer, and other forms of real democracy, perhaps
form our own Commission etc. Direct Action has helped galvanize the
media to report on SP. By not keeping our eyes on the prize, and
only advocate for the "public option", could seriously divide this
movement. Also, by advocating "Medicare for All", it is understood
that the Medicare public option would be the fallback position. Tom
at Schneider drug where i work and i were discussing putting together
a flyer, possible press release, and press conference on this since
it is all over the media right now, and in the public eye.
thanks,
joel