> ...
>
> I think the time has probably come when the regulation of
> reproduction needs to be an issue of talk and debate. For
> example, I don't think a woman has been imprisoned should
> be entitled to become pregnant while she is in prison.
> Would you care to respond to that example?
>
I do see now that I cannot simply preclude "regulation of
reproduction" in the manner I previously suggested. As for this
example, however, I don't think it will fit the topic you proposed.
No woman is entitled to become pregnant, period. Now, as for the
fact that women do have the right to attempt to become pregnant,
through cooperation with those who might impregnate her, this right
would naturally be denied as a side-effect of the denial of freedom
of movement and association that typically comes with imprisonment.
When a woman is precluded from becoming pregant because she is
imprisoned, this isn't a matter of "regulating reproduction" any
more than incidentally preventing her from making pilgrimage to
Mecca would be rightly called regulating religion.
http://www.suntimes.com/output/otherviews/cst-nws-sterile21.html Should Kirsten Johnson be allowed to have kids? August 21, 2005 Chicago Sun-Times BY KATIE...
This issue was hot in the Nethelands a few months back. Our minister of health, apparently after being criticized for shouting off the top of her head, ordered...
Can you provide the website where the research was presented? Is it in English? A major cognitive disability is having a low IQ. How low, of course, has to...
... How would that possibly be applied? (I hesitate to ask, this sounds so bad!) Also, I think we must be extremely suspect of any attempt to deny parental...
Well, you are right. I was rambling. I was thinking of abortion as termination of parental rights. I appreciate what you are saying about the danger of...
... That was what I suspected. I hope you realize that it makes no sense to judge that a person is not taking adequate care of their child, then use that...
I don't get your point about it not making any sense to conclude that a person is not taking adequate care of his child, then using that judgment as an...
... Charles Howard initially suggested that if a pregnant woman were judged criminally negligent with regard to the well-being of her unborn child, the result...
Tracy, I don't believe I made the statement that you claim I made. Your remarks indicate to me that you do not approve of voluntary abortion. Do you think a...
... I do see now that I cannot simply preclude "regulation of reproduction" in the manner I previously suggested. As for this example, however, I don't think...
Good points, Tracy. Notice how we are debating the meaning and connotation of words. What does it mean to "regulate"? If the government passed a law that...
... This does not seem an important aspect of our discussion, to me. ... Yeah, it would. ... So, did my answer confound your expectations, or not? ;) ... In...
... This does not seem an important aspect of our discussion, to me. What does not seem to be an important aspect of our discussion? Are we only going to...
Dear Charles Howard, I am surprised at your reply. Should I interpret the fact that you chose to pay attention to only one sentence as a strong disagreement ...
T.B. Would you mind clarifying your remark that "... attention should be focused on propositions and problems, not definitions and meanings"? Maybe you could...
... Speaking only for myself, I have not participated in this discussion because I have nothing to say about the matter other than that any interference at all...
... The first example that comes to mind is a paper by Karl Popper entitled "A Realist View of Logic, Physics, and History". It was published in _Objective...
I'd like to clarify something that I think was not plain in my prior post. When I wrote about "serious" problems, I had a particular meaning in mind, the...
What are "words"? What is a "plague"? What is a "reason"? What does the word "unfruitful" mean? What is a "game"? A comment about Popper from Szasz's...
<<By the way, what is a "question"?>> As all fans of Airplane: The Movie know: "It's an interrogative form of sentence, used to test knowledge. But that's not...
Shirley, Is that really you? ... But that's not important right now." ... reproduction ... What does the word "unfruitful" mean? What is a "game"? ... with...
I am sure I have seen a statement like the one you make but I don't know where. I think I have read that people of very low intelligence tend not to produce...