Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
sbaofnc · SBANC Talk: Spina Bifida Association of NC Members
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Real people. Real stories. See how Yahoo! Groups impacts members worldwide.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Government to ban research   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #39 of 415 |
Re: Government to ban research; Ethical Dilemma for Me

Bravo! Mike, you are the man. I don't care what anybody thinks. I'm a
new member to the group and have only posted a couple of time. I
received my first Digest of messages today. At first I misunderstood
the posts and thought this club was in favor of embryonic stem cell
research. Thanks to your posts I know otherwise. Though, I'm sure
there may be individual members who are in favor of it. That is their
right and I respect that.

Something that is not often reported in the media (surprise!) is
Adult Stem Cell Research. What's the difference? Embryonic Stem Cell
Research kills a human being. Cloning manufactures a human being so
that we can get the parts we need and this kills them. Adult Stem
Cell Research kills no one and has shown more promise the the other
two above mentioned methods. Those on this list who are interested
can find info on this alternative to harvesting & murdering at this
website www.breakpoint.org. You may have to search a bit, there's
info on a lot of topics at this site.

If holding all life sacred makes me a fundamentalist then, I wear the
banner proud. I'd much rather stand on this side than the side that
would murder for one's own selfish gain, though I'm sure those in
favor of embryonic stem cell research and cloning don't see that this
is way it's doing.

Again, thanks Mike, for such a good post. By the way you had sent me
a post several months ago and I had been away from the club. I sent
you an email in response and never heard back from you. I had wanted
to get on the mailing list and get in touch with some adults will SB.
Seems everything I find on SB is related to children with SB or their
parents. I'm almost 39, these things don't help me much.

Todd

2 Samuel 9, Psalm 73
--- In sbaofnc@y..., mhgates <no_reply@y...> wrote:
> Dear Curesnow:
>
> Thanks for responding. I appreciate your efforts to answer my
> questions honestly. I'm still not clear about your motives
though...
> That it just infuriated you and you needed to do something about
it.
> Why did it infuriate you? Are you a high school or college student?
> Do you own any stock in stem cell companies? Are you or a loved one
> affected in some way? I'm trying to understand where you are coming
> from...
>
> Let me explain my motives and why you may (or may not) have
> difficulty getting support from this group:
>
> I can't speak for everyone here... I want everyone to understand
I'm
> only speaking as an individual now and not as the president of
SBANC
> (even though some of you are not in NC or even the US and my
> involvement in SBA of NC and commitment to the group wouldn't
really
> matter to you anyway). However, if many others feel the way I do
then
> you might have a hard time convincing us to join your efforts.
>
> Would you take the time to hear me out as I have you?
>
> For me this is a huge ethical dilemma much like we faced when we
were
> expecting my daughter -- our first child. I am the father of an 8
> year old girl born with SB... She's had 12 surgeries and uses a
wheel
> chair because it affects her at the T-12 vertabrae. But she has a
> pretty happy life. She loves going to school and has lots of
friends.
> She enjoys playing with her little brother and cousins... She just
> got a (borrowed) handcycle and is having fun riding with us on
bikes
> now in the neighborhood. She plays wheelchair basketball and
tennis.
> She's a very active child. Don't get me wrong; there are some hard
> times. There's anger when people don't seem to care or are just
plain
> ignorant. There will be more as she grows up. But we wouldn't
change
> it for anything!
>
> I'm not sure you understand that SB is something that you can find
> out about ahead of time in a pregnancy. We knew our daughter would
> have it when we were only 5 months along in our pregnancy. The
doctor
> strongly suggested we get an abortion and try again.
>
> But we couldn't. He painted a very bleak picture. But it was
against
> what we know is right because of our faith in God and Jesus Christ.
> Faith is believing in something even when things look bad. It was a
> huge test of our faith. We couldn't do it because our hearts
wouldn't
> let us. God spoke to our hearts and calmed us when everything
seemed
> so crazy. He has been with us the entire time and helped us through
> many situations both related to her health and other things we face
> in life. God has blessed us with both our children. Our daughter is
a
> blessing and we would never change what we decided -- even because
of
> the hard times and the financial burden. God will provide and
honors
> our obedience to His word -- "Do not murder."
> http://bible.gospelcom.net/cgi-bin/bible?
> passage=EXOD+20&language=english&version=NIV&showfn=on&showxref=on
>
> I don't have all the answers. I'm just a Dad with a daughter I love
> very much, a family I love very much and a God I love very much.
>
> But perhaps you can understand my ethical dilemma now -- which
others
> may share in this group or not. Many people just choose to abort
when
> they learn their child will have a disability because it seems
> easiest for everyone. I believe the statistic is over 70 percent
are
> aborted. You can say you are justified because you don't want to
put
> a child through the hardships of life with a disability. But my
> daughter is glad to be alive! I believe everyone on this board is
> glad to have a chance to live life, even though it is hard at
times.
> Even when it hurts sometimes. Maybe some of you had a similar
> experience, or your parents did. My daughter is here because we
> believed God and not the doctor. Even though He has not healed her,
> we know He has a special purpose for her life. We see how she
touches
> people with her love and sincerity. With her determination when it
> would be so much easier just to give up. That she can do all things
> through Christ, who strengthens her. She inspires me.
>
> I have met many of the people in this group personally. And I
believe
> God has a special purpose for your lives too -- whether you know it
> yet or not. You inspire me too. I pray for you.
>
> You may just think of me and my family as the same Fundamentalist
> Christians that are against growing babies to kill them for stem
> cells. Would you dare to walk in our shoes?
>
> Yes, we would like to see our daughter healed. But no, we wouldn't
> want to do it through a means that contradicts why she is here in
the
> first place: Because of our belief in the sanctity of life. That
> every life counts -- even if it faces a disability. And that life
> begins at conception. And we are teaching her our beliefs. And when
> she is an adult, she will make the decision for herself.
>
> Well, now we've opened up a narrow door. What if the stem cells
> worked and you could walk when you never could before? Would you
> still walk through that narrow door?
>
> We will all still die someday too soon unless Jesus Christ comes
back
> before then (because the Bible says we'll be given our glorified
> bodies to serve Him when He does return). But if we die before
that,
> our spirit is taken up to Heaven to be with our God and to worship
> Him. He gave us the right to choose for ourselves to love Him. And
if
> we love Him, we show it by obeying His Word. He doesn't want
puppets,
> but true love from the heart. He sent His only Son, Jesus Christ,
to
> die on the cross for our sins so we could have eternal life and be
> reunited in our relationship with God as we were meant to be.
> http://bible.gospelcom.net/cgi-bin/bible?
> language=english&version=NIV&passage=john+3%3A16-21&version=
>
> We all have our crosses to carry. Sometimes you just have to hold
on
> to what you believe. If holding onto my beliefs makes me a
> fundamentalist, then I guess I am. I pray God will bless you with
> open eyes and a tender heart for those who face hardships with
> disabilities. I don't have all the answers, but He does. Lean on
Him
> for support in the bad times and good.
>
> Sincerely,
>
> Mike
>
>
> --- In sbaofnc@y..., "curesnow" <no1899@e...> wrote:
> > Hi! I wanted to reply right away to clear up a couple of points:
> > 1. I am not spamming! Ok, so I don't really know the
definitions
> > of spamming, but I think it means dropping lots of information
> > indescriminantly everywhere and not following up. That's not
> > me.
> > 2. No, I do not know anyone personally with SB. That does not
> > mean I don't care.
> > 3. I am not from North Carolina. But as we go along, you'll see
> > why I have contacted you.
> > 4. I am not a lobbyist, nor do I work for a biotech company. I
am
> > an advocate, i guess, for those who will be afffected by this
> > Brownback Bill, which just so infuriated me I had to do
> > something. That's why I am trying to get the word out to the 12
> > states whose Senators are strongly considering backing this
bill.
> > My Senator is against it. It wasn't enough for me to just be
glad
> > about that!
> >
> > Now, most importantly- how does this research pertain to SB? I
> > will get you some answers and some links as fast as I can. I
> > have piles of them to sort through, but I wanted to write
> > immediately first.
> > Some basic sites? www.nih.org, or there are great articles on
> > www.nejm.com (do a search on thier site)




Fri Jun 7, 2002 3:10 pm

jcfreak1984
Offline Offline

Forward
Message #39 of 415 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

North Carolina raise your voice for cures: Do you think that our government should allow its citizens to use the most promising technology available to create...
curesnow
Offline Send Email
Jun 6, 2002
6:43 pm

Interesting... I have a few questions, unless you're just spamming us. Because you seem to cover a lot of territory... and you just joined the group today......
mhgates
Offline
Jun 6, 2002
8:27 pm

Hi! I wanted to reply right away to clear up a couple of points: 1. I am not spamming! Ok, so I don't really know the definitions of spamming, but I think...
curesnow
Offline Send Email
Jun 6, 2002
9:59 pm

Dear Curesnow: Thanks for responding. I appreciate your efforts to answer my questions honestly. I'm still not clear about your motives though... That it just...
mhgates
Offline
Jun 7, 2002
4:45 am

Bravo! Mike, you are the man. I don't care what anybody thinks. I'm a new member to the group and have only posted a couple of time. I received my first Digest...
jcfreak1984
Offline
Jun 7, 2002
3:10 pm

I do applaud the choices you have made, Mike. They are the same choices, I truly believe, that I would make. Our personal beliefs in all of this are vital to...
curesnow
Offline Send Email
Jun 7, 2002
5:40 pm

Hello, Emily! Thank you for your kind response! I apologize that I couldn't reply sooner, but we're working on the program logistics and communications for an...
mhgates
Offline
Jun 10, 2002
2:05 pm

Hi- Actually, adult stem cells have not shown to be as promisiing as embryonic stem cells, which is the real crux of the argument for research to go forward....
curesnow
Offline Send Email
Jun 10, 2002
5:57 pm

Hello, Todd! Thanks for you support! And welcome to SBANC! I apologize that I haven't been able to respond very quickly to this or your earlier e- mail. We are...
mhgates
Offline
Jun 10, 2002
1:53 pm

... cell ... Certainly there was misinterpretation, but let's not get caught up in one person's opinion being representative of the WHOLE group (it might be...
prplbutterfly
Offline
Jun 10, 2002
2:15 pm

Thanks, Monica! I agree that all opinions are welcome here! That's why I began my original post with that I was only speaking as an individual and not ...
mhgates
Offline
Jun 10, 2002
2:29 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help