Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
rosacea-support · Rosacea, more than just a red face !
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Hear how Yahoo! Groups has changed the lives of others. Take me there.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Re: [rosacea] Re: Rosacea and pathogen link?   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #93579 of 104842 |
[rosacea] Re: Rosacea and pathogen link?

Hi Steve & Aurelia,

Thanks for the very nice remarks!

Steve, asking about my background is not too personal at all. I
really do not have any medical background at all. I have a a
business background and spent most of my career as an IT consultant.

Best of luck with your degree though Steve. It's an exciting field,
and I believe a very exciting time to be going into it. I'm sure
you'll do well, and I have to admit, I'm a bit jealous. If I were
younger, I might seriously think of a career along these lines.


After several years of really getting nowhere with traditional
treatments for my rosacea and hearing again and again from some really
great dermatologists that nobody knows why some people get rosacea or
why this or that works with rosacea, I started doing some research on
my own, mostly by searching through pubmed articles and googling terms
from the articles when I didn't understand them. Aurelia and David
suggested we put together the RSRP, and in doing the necessary
research, I started seeing some patterns emerging, namely:

1. That rosacea has an chronic inflammatory nature. Remember this
is still just a theory, but one that seems to be gaining acceptance in
the medical community.

2. That the inflammatory pathology of rosacea (i.e. the dilated,
leaky blood vessels and the resulting inflammatory mediators
(cytokines, MMPs, etc) that cause much localized barrier and tissue
destruction and barrier disruption, matches the model of low grade
sepsis, thus indicating to me the involvement of some sort of
gram-negative type bacteria in the bloodstream. Note that this is way
outside mainstream theory on rosacea, as most in the medical community
seem to think that the inflammation associated with rosacea is the
result of some sort of autoimmune or allergic type response.

3. That since the inflammation associated with rosacea is chronic,
any pathogen causing it must also cause a chronic or persistent
infection.

4. That since very little research into the actual pathology behind
rosacea has been done, we should look to the research behind other
diseases of similar pathology (i.e. those diseases that also involve
chronically dilated and leaky blood vessels that cause localized
tissue destruction and barrier disruption). Multiple Sclerosis,
Asthma, Crohn's Disease and Interstitial Cystitis fit this bill
nicely. Again, though, it's apparent and unfortunate that most in
the very compartmentalized medical community don't realize that these
diseases share similar pathologies. Neurologists, Pulmunologists,
Gastroenterologists, Urologists and Dermotologists don't share
research very well.

5. That respiratory pathogen Chlamydia Pneumoniae (Cpn) has been
implicated in all of the above diseases, including even rosacea via a
very small study, and has been shown to infect and persist in many
different organs in the body, including most interestingly the
epithelial cells of the blood vessels, causing much localized
inflammation including dilated and leaky blood vessels and the
resulting tissue destruction and barrier disruption found in the above
diseases. While Cpn has not been shown to cause any of these other
diseases (the nature of medical science makes for very slow acceptance
of cause), more and more research indicates at least a secondary
involvement.

6. That the barrier disruption associated with the above pathogen can
lead to the types of reactions to topicals and other pathogens (like
demodex, the fungi/yeasts of seb derm, etc) that we see with rosacea.
Again, this is way outside mainstream medical thought on rosacea.


Remember too all this is just anecdotal evidence I have put together
myself. I have confirmed my theory with a couple of very helpful
microbiologists who see no fault with my line of reasoning, but it is
far from mainstream medical beliefs about rosacea. And most of all
this is just a theory. It just makes a lot of common sense to me.

Here's where I believe my background in IT helps. In IT, if you have
a "bug" in a system, you quickly go through a process of narrowing
down the possibilities one by one, rather than just trying anything
you can think of to fix the bug. Otherwise you'll spend enormous
amounts of time and effort trying to fix the "bug". And if I were
going to build a new system from scratch, I would first research and
list all requirements for the system, review the requirements and
design a system, then build the system, potentially making a few
assumptions along the way, but always testing these assumptions ASAP
to make sure they are correct before proceeding. Sitting back and
looking at what we know about rosacea (and similar diseases) makes
sense in my mind. Just trialling another topical of unknown action
against rosacea and counting the number of p&p's seems like the long
way to solve the problem.

Most of all, I've learned in my old age that common sense almost
always rules and magic rarely occurs. That I would somehow at the
ripe old age of 35, magically get an autoimmune or allergic type
rosacea out of the blue makes no common sense to me. That it might
be caused by infection, seems much less magical...

Dan

--- In rosacea-support@yahoogroups.com, Aurelia <aurelia.dawn@...> wrote:
>
> Hi Steve,
>
> It is definitely not my place to speak for Dan, but he is an
extremely modest man, so ...
>
> In his role as RSRP Editor, he does almost all of the work on our
Resource Pages single-handed. As one of his occasional helpers, I can
say that we're always impressed by the depth of his knowledge about
biochemistry. In well over a year, I can count his mistakes on the
fingers of one hand and still have plenty of fingers left to stir my
coffee spoon. ;)
>
> Good luck with your degree, Steve. May we ask what you intend to do
with it?
>
> Kind regards,
>
> Aurelia
>





Sat Mar 17, 2007 4:22 pm

dfries2003
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #93579 of 104842 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Hi Steve, It is definitely not my place to speak for Dan, but he is an extremely modest man, so ... In his role as RSRP Editor, he does almost all of the work...
Aurelia
aurelia_aurora
Offline Send Email
Mar 17, 2007
12:46 pm

Hi Steve & Aurelia, Thanks for the very nice remarks! Steve, asking about my background is not too personal at all. I really do not have any medical...
dfries2003
Offline Send Email
Mar 17, 2007
4:30 pm

Very well said, Dan! Thanks for sharing your ideas. Be sure to keep us informed on the pathogen front. And thanks so much for the work you do on the RSRPs. ...
nurse_artist
Offline Send Email
Mar 17, 2007
6:15 pm

... Extremely interesting. I'm almost persuaded. But if C. pneumoniae were a causative factor in rosacea, would there not be a correlation between rosacea and...
Emma Waghorn
redactionuk
Offline Send Email
Mar 17, 2007
10:57 pm

Hi Emma, Great questions and certainly ones I've thought about as well. I'm certainly no expert on Cpn, but hopefully I can help answer some of these. First,...
dfries2003
Offline Send Email
Mar 18, 2007
8:22 pm

Hi Emma, One other point I left out is the potential for other environmental factors to influence disease. As several of the studies I've included before...
dfries2003
Offline Send Email
Mar 18, 2007
10:55 pm

Hi Dan, One of the things I like about your ideas about Cpn is that is gives us a unifying model of rosacea. We dance around at symptoms and triggers so much...
David Pascoe
pascoedj
Offline Send Email
Mar 19, 2007
1:33 am

Hi David, Thanks for the encouraging remarks. And I agree about the unifying model this creates for rosacea, and feel that this in itself may be one of the...
dfries2003
Offline Send Email
Mar 19, 2007
4:43 am

HI Dan, What does treatment for Cpn involve and can we just ramdomly ask our doctor to do this? I don't remember reading if there was a test to see if you...
Elena Mutter
emgm42000
Offline Send Email
Mar 19, 2007
7:40 pm

Hi Elena, Most physicians probably wouldn't know all that much about Chlamydia pneumonaie unfortunately, particularly about how it can cause chronic ...
dfries2003
Offline Send Email
Mar 20, 2007
2:24 am

Thank you Dan. I wish you good luck with this. It really sounds promising. Seems we are a world inundated with chronic issues. They are very tiring!...
Elena Mutter
emgm42000
Offline Send Email
Mar 21, 2007
2:18 pm

Hi Dan, Thanks for all the information on Cpn and all the links. I went to the website you provided @cpnhelp.org and found it fascinationg. It is a lot of...
melissa wohl-battista
melissawohlb...
Offline Send Email
Mar 19, 2007
8:30 pm

Hi Melissa, Thanks. Did you find the handbook on cpnhelp? If you're interested, it has been created to try to simplify some of the very complicated...
dfries2003
Offline Send Email
Mar 20, 2007
1:45 am

Yes I did Dan. I printed all 121 pages of the handbook and am looking forward to reading it. Thanks again for all your hard work! Best wishes, Melissa ...
melissa wohl-battista
melissawohlb...
Offline Send Email
Mar 20, 2007
2:28 am

Hi Melissa & All, Also don't miss the Stratton Slide presentation (I don't think it prints with the handbook) as it summarizes some important points about Cpn...
dfries2003
Offline Send Email
Mar 20, 2007
5:24 am

Thanks Dan. The Stratton slide presentation was quite good. It brought me back to my college days filled with bio and chem classes. Best wishes, Melissa ...
melissa wohl-battista
melissawohlb...
Offline Send Email
Mar 21, 2007
2:17 pm

Hi Dan, I seem to be missing quite a few board posts - like this one never made it to my inbox for some reason :( Thus I'm replying via the board. About all I...
dpatiidotnet
Offline Send Email
Mar 20, 2007
1:45 am

Thanks David. I'll keep plugging away at this, and these are some great ideas. One of the good things about having the recently added article on the cpnhelp...
dfries2003
Offline Send Email
Mar 20, 2007
3:19 am

Dan, thanks for that summary, you state your case very clearly. I know what you mean about "bugs", I do some programming as a hobby, and debugging really...
steve95301
Offline Send Email
Mar 19, 2007
4:40 am

Thanks, Steve. I hope you will find exactly the right career. Kind regards, Aurelia...
Aurelia
aurelia_aurora
Offline Send Email
Mar 19, 2007
7:46 am

Hi Dan, If I may, just one little suggestion for making it slightly easier for the rest of us to follow your trains of thought. If you use initials not...
Aurelia
aurelia_aurora
Offline Send Email
Mar 19, 2007
7:47 am

YES!!! Please! I don't know many of these..... RA is Rheumatoid Arthritis? CFS is Chronic Fatigue Syndrome? FMS is ??????? I'm assuming (and you know...
ellen lafrancis
ellenlafrancis
Offline Send Email
Mar 19, 2007
2:23 pm

Hi all, Sorry, but yes Ellen. RA = rheumatoid arthritis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rheumatoid_arthritis CFS = chronic fatigue syndrome ...
dfries2003
Offline Send Email
Mar 19, 2007
7:38 pm

Hi Dan, Regarding your comments about studies seeming to suggest that Vitamin D3 promotes antimicrobial protection against pathogens and may also downregulate...
Aurelia
aurelia_aurora
Offline Send Email
Mar 19, 2007
7:47 am

Hi Aurelia, This probably sounds very strange given what we've always been told about staying out of the sun, and as you've probably heard (and should know if...
dfries2003
Offline Send Email
Mar 19, 2007
7:38 pm

HI Aurelia, I know this is for Dan, but just thought I'd let you know that for years now I have gone out in the early morning hours when the sun is at its...
Elena Mutter
emgm42000
Offline Send Email
Mar 19, 2007
7:39 pm

I'm with you on this. I live in a pretty hot, humid climate so it's easy to WANT to avoid sun but I will go out before 10:00 and then MAYBE later on -- after...
ellen lafrancis
ellenlafrancis
Offline Send Email
Mar 20, 2007
2:21 am

Thanks for the reply, Dan. Moi on a sun lounger? Never! Yes to the floppy sunhat, but no to everything else. I shall weed the garden while playing with our...
Aurelia
aurelia_aurora
Offline Send Email
Mar 20, 2007
5:23 am

THanks Aurelia and you're welcome. ~Elena Aurelia <aurelia.dawn@...> wrote: Thanks for the reply, Dan. Moi on a sun lounger? Never! Yes to the floppy...
Elena Mutter
emgm42000
Offline Send Email
Mar 20, 2007
5:23 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help