Having problems with message search?
I agree with Frank . I have read this book and most of what he says is logical and reasonable for anyone suffering from a disease possibly resulting from a 'Western' life-style i.e diet, stress levels, insufficient exercise
I think the lengthy chapter on sex is unnecessary and assumes you are married or have a sexual partner.
I am also disappointed that he has written/co-written other books such as 'Awaken the Healer Within' and 'The Fat-Blocker Diet'. Kind of changes him from a prostate cancer sufferer with a story to tell into a medical author.
Pelham
----- Original Message -----From: fundprophetSent: Saturday, June 05, 2004 7:32 PMSubject: [NTPC Yahoo Group] Reply to Sammy re Larry Clapp's Book--- In natural_prostate_treatments@yahoogroups.com, "sammy_bates"
<sammy_bates@b...> wrote:
> Larry is on the right track, but he has never to my knowledge
disclosed his
> PC biology. It is important to know what his starting point was, so
his end
> point can be properly evaluated. Did he have objective clinical
disease, or
> did he have subjective symptoms? What was his bPSA and DRE
assessment? Did
> he have any imaging to show the state of his prostate? Without
these facts
> at hand anyone can claim a cure for just about anything and get
away with it
> so long as the rest of us are gullible enough to believe it. Sammy.
> http://uk.geocities.com/prostate.man@b.../
Sammy,
You're absolutely right about Larry Clapp's book. I think the only
information he gives about his condition is his PSA and prostate
size, which is virtually worthless information in the absence of
knowing his tumor staging and Gleason score. Thank you for making
that point.
However, I don't think this completely invalidates his work, because
most of what he recommends is a good preventative regimen even if you
don't have a prostate problem, and may help cure other disorders
besides cancer.
Frank
========================================
ALL INFORMATION APPEARING ON THIS NEWSGROUP REPRESENTS OPINIONS OFFERED BY NON-MEDICALLY TRAINED LAYPERSONS. COMMENTS POSTED HERE SHOULD NEVER BE INTERPRETED AS MEDICAL ADVICE AND MUST ONLY BE USED AS BACKGROUND INFORMATION WHEN CONSULTING WITH A QUALIFIED CONSULTANT FROM A QUALIFIED MEDICAL PROFESSION. FOR THE PURPOSE OF THIS GROUP ALL POSTINGS MUST BE CONSIDERED TO BE THE ADVICE OF NON-MEDICALLY TRAINED LAYPEOPLE REGARDLESS OF ANY INDIVIDUAL CONTRIBUTOR'S MEDICAL OR NON-MEDICAL BACKGROUND.
Discussions on this web group in the United States are protected by the First Amendment of the United States Constitution. Attempts to persecute participants in this group for opinions stated will be considered a violation of the First Amendment and may be prosecuted as such.
-------------------------------
The "Natural Treatments for Prostate Cancer" Yahoo Newsgroup is an open forum for the sharing of all knowledge and information regarding natural treatments and remedies for Prostate Cancer. This group includes discussions of PC-SPES, Prostasol and any other natural products which contribute to prostate health. All messages posted here are public domain and are accessible to anyone wishing to read them. Members are represented by their Yahoo Profile name, not their e-mail address. E-mail addresses are kept hidden to the best of our abilities.
To SUBSCRIBE: send e-mail to natural_prostate_treatments-subscribe@yahoogroups.com
To UNSUBSCRIBE: send an email to:
natural_prostate_treatments-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
The Group web page is: http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/natural_prostate_treatments/
All messages can be viewed from this page.
Information on efforts to create a new, pure, drug-free PC-Spes is available at the Natural Approaches to Prostate Cancer website at http://www.napc.info
Information on Prostasol is available at http://www.donsbach.com/products/male.htm
Prostasol supplier: 201-432-0169
Offline 
Send Email