Hi Brattatoo,

There is a member of this club whose Father had hip problems. I
guess they operate on one and then the other after the first
operation heals. Well he disliked the operation so much he decided
to really try the vitamins as a last hope to maybe not have to do it
again. They fixed his hip and now the one that was operated on is
the problem one!

My Grandfather also had hip pain and tried everything short of
operation, he has been on the vitamins now for aalmost a year and has
no hip pain. It went away gradually. He takes the Ultimate Classic,
Cherimins, OsteoCal, EFA, GlucoGel and CM+

Hope this helps.

Brian

--- In deaddoctorsdontlie2@y..., "brattatoo" <brattatoo@y...> wrote:
> My grandson has lost the cartilege in his left hip and now the
right
> one is starting to hurt and he thinks it is going too. The Drs.
say
> that it looks OK, but we are very worried. It is not arthritis,
but
> the immune system seems to be involved. He is only 16. Can anyone
> tell me about a similar case where Dr. Wallach's products have
> helped. I haven't yet tried the products myself but plan to do so.