Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
bigbookmeeting · The Online Big Book Study
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Real people. Real stories. See how Yahoo! Groups impacts members worldwide.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Big Book Study - Post #5   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #7293 of 8322 |
Big Book Study - Post #5

Good Morning!

We're at paragraph 1, page xxvi, right after the first
letter. "...the body of the alcoholic is quite as abnormal as his
mind." This was a radical idea for 1935. The primary reason for the
lack of signature by Dr. Silkworth was his reluctance to attach his
name to such radical ideas; it was The Depression and he, too,
was lucky to have a position. Further down it is restated, "...any
picture of the alcoholic which leaves out this physical factor is
incomplete."

Throughout the book, Bill will restate the same idea in several
different ways to reinforce the importance or significance of the
idea. He does this with the allergy theory. Having an allergy means
that we react abnormally to something; in this case we react
abnormally to alcohol. (Some drunks claim to break out in handcuffs
when drinking. Other claim to break out in strange spots – like
another town, some strange neighborhood, or jail.)

Dr. Silkworth continues to expand on his ideas on page xxviii.
Paragraph 2 is important here:

"...the action of alcohol on these chronic alcoholics is a
manifestation of an allergy; that the phenomenon of craving is
limited to this class and never occurs in the average temperate
drinker."

We are different than other people. Average or normal people do not
develop the phenomenon of "craving." We metabolize alcohol in a
different way than the "normal" drinker. They don't experience the
physical craving which comes after the first drink is taken. They
can have the one or two that we, as a class, cannot. They don't have
the mental obsession that precedes the first drink.

Paragraph 3, at the bottom, is where "...restless, irritable and
discontented" comes from.

Continuing at the top of page xxix, "the sense of ease and
comfort...drinks they see others taking with impunity" (without
repercussions). Normal drinkers don't have this physical malady;
that's why they can drink and we can't.

The last sentence of the top paragraph gives us an example of what
we will see throughout the book – what the spiritual awakening is –
"...unless this person can experience an entire psychic change (also
known as a "spiritual awakening") there is very little hope of his
recovery."

Strong words. Over and over we will see that CHANGE is the hallmark
of recovery from alcoholism.

Turn to page xxx - Silkworth describes five types of alcoholics:

"the psychopaths who are emotionally unstable..."
"There is the type of man who is unwilling to admit that he cannot
take a drink..."
"There is the type who believes that after being entirely free from
alcohol for a period of time he can take a drink without danger."
"There is the manic-depressive type..."
"Then there are types entirely normal in every respect except in the
effect alcohol has upon them."

Here's the important point: "All these, and many others, have one
symptom in common: they cannot start drinking without developing the
phenomenon of craving...the manifestation of an allergy..." That
first drink does get you drunk - that's the how and why of it.

With our next post we'll start with Chapter 1 - Bill's Story. Until
then think about this: there is only one place in the main text of
the Big Book where the word "pot" appears. No, it isn't the kind you
smoke. What is it's meaning? We'll reveal its meaning with our next
post.

Have a great day!

Jim








Tue Jan 3, 2006 1:02 pm

sottovoice
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #7293 of 8322 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Good Morning! We're at paragraph 1, page xxvi, right after the first letter. "...the body of the alcoholic is quite as abnormal as his mind." This was a...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Nov 2, 2005
12:37 pm

Good Morning! We're at paragraph 1, page xxvi, right after the first letter. "...the body of the alcoholic is quite as abnormal as his mind." This was a...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Jan 3, 2006
1:06 pm

Good morning! While we continue to study the forwords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Karen
honey_dot_com
Offline Send Email
Mar 1, 2006
1:34 pm

Good morning! While we continue to study the forwords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Karen
honey_dot_com
Offline Send Email
Apr 26, 2006
12:07 pm

[Wednesday Post] Good morning! While we continue to study the forwords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Jun 21, 2006
2:39 am

Good morning! While we continue to study the forwords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Aug 17, 2006
7:13 pm

Good morning! While we continue to study the forwords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Karen
honey_dot_com
Offline Send Email
Oct 13, 2006
12:00 pm

Good morning! (Tuesday Post) While we continue to study the forwords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering ...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Dec 12, 2006
2:24 am

Good morning! While we continue to study the forwords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Feb 12, 2007
10:51 am

Good morning! While we continue to study the forewords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Apr 10, 2007
12:30 pm

Good morning! While we continue to study the forwords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Apr 11, 2007
1:05 pm

Good morning! While we continue to study the forwords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Karen
honey_dot_com
Offline Send Email
Jun 7, 2007
12:14 pm

Good morning! While we continue to study the forwords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Karen
honey_dot_com
Offline Send Email
Aug 3, 2007
3:32 am

Good morning! While we continue to study the forwords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Karen
honey_dot_com
Offline Send Email
Oct 1, 2007
4:12 am

Good morning! While we continue to study the forewords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Nov 28, 2007
10:59 am

Good morning! While we continue to study the forewords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Jan 30, 2008
2:17 pm

Good morning! While we continue to study the forewords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Mar 28, 2008
12:50 am

Good morning! While we continue to study the forewords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
May 27, 2008
11:23 am

Good morning! While we continue to study the forewords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Jul 24, 2008
12:19 pm

Good morning! While we continue to study the forewords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Sep 22, 2008
12:00 pm

Good morning! While we continue to study the forewords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering prior to...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Nov 17, 2008
1:16 pm

Good morning! Welcome back on this historic day! While we continue to study the forewords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition....
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Jan 20, 2009
1:09 pm

Good morning! Welcome back! While we continue to study the forewords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering ...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Mar 19, 2009
12:03 pm

Good morning! Welcome back! While we continue to study the forewords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering ...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
May 14, 2009
10:26 am

Good morning! Welcome back! While we continue to study the forewords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering ...
Jim K.
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Jul 13, 2009
12:12 pm

Good morning! Welcome back! While we continue to study the forewords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering ...
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Sep 8, 2009
12:50 pm

Good morning! Welcome back! While we continue to study the forewords and the Doctor's Opinion, remember that we are using the 4th Edition. (The page numbering ...
Jim
sottovoice
Offline Send Email
Nov 10, 2009
12:53 pm
 First  |  |  Next > Last 
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help