Medical journal slams popularity of homoeopathy in India
http://www.earthtimes.org/articles/show/142896.html
Posted : Fri, 16 Nov 2007 05:04:01 GMT
Author : IANS

London, Nov 16 - Even as homeopathy gains popularity in India, it is
coming under pressure in Britain, with a proposed seminar on its role
in the treatment of HIV/AIDS sparking protests.

The seminar, organised by the Society of Homeopaths and scheduled to
be held here on Dec 1, has invited criticism from Michael Baum,
professor emeritus of surgery at the University College London (UCL),
according to the medical journal The Lancet.

The Lancet has also slammed the growing popularity of homeopathy in
India.

'People say homoeopathy cannot do any harm but when it is being
promoted for HIV then there is a serious problem,' Baum is quoted as
saying in a two-part special report in the medical journal.

Baum and others had sent a letter last May to all primary care trusts
in Britain to voice concern about homoeopathy treatment through the
National Health Service (NHS).

Seemingly in response, one trust stopped NHS funding for the
Tunbridge Wells Homeopathic Hospital, one of five that provide
homoeopathy treatment on the NHS.

Despite this, says the report, homoeopathy remains popular with the
public, with the 2007 market estimated to be worth 38 million pounds
($78 million). This figure is expected to rise to 46 million pounds
in 2012.

Baum believes the public backs homeopathy in the belief that it is
herbal medicine.

'Although many herbal medicines are unproven, they, unlike
homoeopathic remedies, have scientific plausibility,' he said.

Several studies, including one by The Lancet, have shown that the
clinical effects of homoeopathic remedies are placebo effects.

The report also focuses on the thriving homoeopathy industry in
India, where an estimated 100 million people depend solely on this
form of therapy for their health care.

It refers to the case of a man who sold his tractor to pay the
Rs.150,000 to pay for a miracle homoeopathic cure for HIV, which had
no effect.