Hi;
I'm newly diagnosed with Kienbock's and my doctor is recommending a
proximal row carpectomy. Seems kind of drastic, but he's telling me
that it's my best option to keep the most motion and strength. I'm
experiencing moderate pain, but it's manageable with immobilization
anti-inflammatory over the counter medicine. Has anyone had this
procedure? Any thoughts?
sat in the chair, looked around the roo as usual... dr culp walks in, says
sooo.... show me wot uve got. i make hand level w/ arm, thatsgood, next
move upward, i do wot i can, then he takes hand and moves it move, releases
and hand went back to where i last had it. ok relax, takes a breath and now
yes u got it, move down. ok place elbow on table, brings up arm like if im
gonna arm wrestle sum1,lol. i let hand slowly move downward. i dont know the
degree u wod call it but if u were looking at a clock, finger tips point
to.....10 oclock , should be 8 oclock like left, but once wrist is in this
position, barbie can jump off the stiffest diving board , pmsl. sooooo.....
now he says hmmmm..... make a fist. ok i gave him eveything i had, made the
nicest fist, so proud............ok, great, bend it back,in fist,moves just
off the 12 oclock, no where near the 1, lol. (about 1/4 of an inch) ok, now
bend other way for me plz....well thats my biggest problem, see it dont move
that way. looks like it moves abit, but not noticeable. then he did sum
rotating of the wrist and it cracks or pops, however u want to say it. i
told him of the many types of pain i have, and wot it is im doing that cuz
the pain. i get this pain over unla bone that spreads out to arm and fingers
making a up n down motion, then if i try the "open/ close jar" i get
stabbing pain over where the transfer to the thumb is. still get pin/needle
throughout the day. i tried to explain that the pain feels like its in the
bones, not the soft tissue, n the stabbing pains feels like sumting
tearing. he also now thinks that arthrisis is setting in, like b4 injury, i
had no pains wot so ever. he did say "kath, u have a hand that can function
with sum limitations, u may not get back much more movemnt. the pain should
go away in due time, lets try working on getting ur hand and arm stronger
now.(at moment wrking with 3 lb weight, boy it hurts ,lol) so on this
tuesday i will have eval for work conditioning. oh n the funny thing about
therapy is that they seem to have just noticed that the wrist doesnt bend
downward, even after i mention (more than 7 times) that i cant,lol, they
were too busy worried about getting my palm up and fingers moving they over
looked that problem, also not much was done with thumb other then the
exerices they show me in the beginning, they did do sum stretching atfer
heat with the thumb. i have no problem with how the treatments are being
handled.just times they get so focused on 1 thing.
4 - 1/2 months after 2nd opt..... i feel like i know wots ahead of me, need
to face the fact that it wont be "normal" again. i try everyday to do things
that i havent been able to do, like starting car, wiping is still painful,
cant from behind, shoulder wont let me get arm back there but i try. washing
the dishes better now, still cant scrub hard. with everything else, the
right hand makes the effort to assist left hand in chores.
work, sounds odd to say that word, seeing i havent been there in 9 mos.
3 weeks ago called work to cash in last of vacation/sick/personal days
(seeing that wrk/comp dropped me, and disability pay ended,i was told i
could cash in, but after that there wont be anything else) .i was told had
to be 100% before i could return. they asked when i was coming back, told
them i will find out on the 5th of feb. that the dr hasnt said yet.that i
wod let them know after the appointmnt.
bad thing to do, work terminated me as of Jan. 31st. for "no show" of 3
consective days from day i called them,which is a breech of contract with
the union. i see that as very funny, seeing that the rules from being out on
disability states that i cant return if not 100%! just 1 more hurdle in my
life, making lawyer earn his money now,pmsl....still wont let self cry over
it, it was expected.
i guess this is enof for me now.... love u all, try to have a pain free day,
kathy
Kienbock Disease Australia - CHAT TWO - GIRLS DAY OUT
Tuesday February 8, 2005 9:00 am
- 1:00 pm
This event repeats every week.
Event Location: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/KienbockDisease_Australia/chat
Notes:
Check your Location for Times
US Pac/Vancouver - 3.00pm Mondays US East/Toronto/Montreal - 6.00pm Mondays London/GMT - 11.00pm Mondays Amsterdam/Rome/Paris/Vienna/Prague/Stockholm/Lisbon - Midnight Mondays Pretoria - South Africa - 1.00am Tuesdays Kuwait City - 2am Tuesdays Phillipines - 7.00am Tuesdays Australia - 7.00am West AST Tuesdays Australia - 9.00am AEST Tuesdays Australia - 10.00am AEDST Tuesdays New Zealand - 11.00am Tuesdays
Kienbock Disease Australia - CHAT ONE - All Members Welcome
Monday February 7, 2005 9:00 am
- 1:00 pm
This event repeats every week.
Event Location: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/KienbockDisease_Australia/chat
Notes:
Check your location for Times
US Pac/Vancouver -3.00pm Sundays US East/Toronto/Montreal - 6.00pm sundays London/GMT - 11.00pm Sundays Amsterdam/Rome/Paris/Vienna/Prague/Stockholm/Lisbon - Midnight Sundays Pretoria - South Africa - 1.00am Mondays Kuwait City - 2.00am Mondays Phillipines - 7.00am Mondays Australia - 7.00am West AST Mondays Australia - 9.00am AEST Mondays Australia - 10.00am AEDST Mondays New Zealand - 11.00am Mondays
Kienbock Disease Australia - CHAT TEN - COUPLES CHAT - TWO
Sunday February 6, 2005 9:30 pm
- 1:30 am
This event repeats every week.
Event Location: http://grpous.yahoo.com/group/KienbockDisease_Australia/chat
Notes:
Check your Location for Times
US Pac/Vancouver - 3.30am Sundays US East/Toront/Montreal - 6.30am Sundays London/GMT - 11.30am Sundays Amsterdam/Rome/Paris/Vienna/Prague/Stockholm/Lisbon - 12.30pm Sundays Pretoria - South Africa - 1.30pm Sundays Kuwait City - 2.30pm Sundays Phillipines - 7.30pm Sundays Australia - 7.30pm West AST Sundays Australia - 9.30pm AEST Sundays Australia 10.30pm AEDST Sundays New Zealand - 11.30pm Sundays
Kienbock Disease Australia - CHAT NINE - BLOKES BASH
Sunday February 6, 2005 11:30 am
- 3:30 pm
This event repeats every week.
Event Location: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/KienbockDisease_Australia/chat
Notes:
Check your Location for Times
US Pac/Vancouver - 5.30pm Saturdays US East/Toronto/Montreal - 8.30pm Saturdays London/GMT - 1.30am Sundays Amsterdam/Rome/Paris/Vienna/Prague/Stockholm/Lisbon - 2.30am Sundays Pretoria - South Africa - 3.30am Sundays Kuwait City - 4.30am Sundays Phillipines - 9.30am Sundays Australia - 9.30am West AST Sundays Australia - 11.30am AEST Sundays Australia - 12.30pm AEDST Sundays New Zealand - 1.30pm Sundays
Kienbock Disease Australia - Chat 8-ALL MEMBERS WELCOME
Sunday February 6, 2005 5:30 am
- 9:30 am
This event repeats every week.
Event Location: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/KienbockDisease_Australia/chat
Notes:
Check your Locations for Times
US Pac/Vancouver - 11.30am Saturdays US East/Toronto/Montreal - 2.30pm Saturdays London/GMT - 7.30pm Saturdays Amsterdam/Rome/Paris/Vienna/Prague/Stockholm/Lisbon - 8.30pm Saturdays Pretoria - South Africa - 9.30pm Saturdays Kuwait City - 10.30pm Saturdays Phillipines - 3.30am Sundays Australia - 3.30am West AST Sundays Australia - 5.30am AST Sundays Australia - 6.30 ASDST Sundays New Zealand - 7.30am Sundays
Kienbock Disease Australia: CHAT SEVEN - GIRLS NIGHT OUT - TWO
Saturday February 5, 2005 5:30 am
- 9:30 am
This event repeats every week.
Event Location: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/KienbockDisease_Australia/chat
Notes:
Check your Location for Times
US Pac/Vancouver - 11.30am Fridays US East/Toronto/montreal - 2.30pm Fridays London/GMT - 7.30pm Fridays Amsterdam/Rome/Paris/Vienna/Prague/Stockholm/Lisbon - 8.30pm Fridays Pretoria - South Africa - 9.30pm Fridays Kuwait City - 10.30pm Fridays Phillipines - 3.30am Saturdays Australia - 3.30am West AST Saturdays Australia - 5.30am AEST Saturdays Australia - 6.30am AEDST Saturdays New Zealand - 7.30am Saturdays
Kienbock Disease Australia - CHAT SIX - GIRLS NIGHT OUT - ONE
Friday February 4, 2005 7:30 pm
- 11:30 pm
This event repeats every week.
Event Location: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/KienbockDisease_Australia/chat
Notes:
Check your Location for Times
US Pac/Vancouver - 1.30am Fridays US East/Toronto/Montreal - 4.30am Fridays London/GMT - 9.30am Fridays Amsterdam/Rome/Paris/Vienna/Stoockholm/Lisbon - 10.30am Fridays Pretoria - South Africa - 11.30am Fridays Kuwait City - 12.30pm Fridays Phillipines - 5.30pm Fridays Australia - 5.30pm WEest AST Fridays Australia - 7.30pm AEST Fridays Australia - 8.30pm AEDST Fridays New Zealand - 9.30pm Fridays
Kienbock Disease Australia: CHAT FIVE - PARTNERS OF A K'DER CHAT
Friday February 4, 2005 12:00 pm
- 4:00 pm
This event repeats every week.
Event Location: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/KienbockDisease_Australia/chat
Notes:
Check your Location for Times
US Pac/Vancouver - 6.00pm Thursdays Us East/Toronto/Montreal - 9.00pm Thursdays Londom/GMT - 2.00am Fridays Amsterdam/Rome/Paris/Vienna/Prague/Stockholm/Lisbon - 3.00am Fridays Pretoria Sth Africa - 4.00am Fridays Kuwait City - 5.00am Fridays Phillipines - 10.00am Fridays Australia - 10.00am West AST Fridays Australia - 12noon AEST Fridays Australia - 1.00pm AEDST Fridays New Zealand - 2.00pm Fridays
Congrats Col. Sounds successful to me. My scars were only an inch and a half
and I thought that was great.
john
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
Kienbock Disease Australia - CHAT FOUR - MID WEEK CHAT - ALL MEMBERS WELCOME
Wednesday February 2, 2005 7:30 pm
- 11:30 pm
This event repeats every week.
Event Location: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/KienbockDisease_Australia/chat
Notes:
Check your location for Times
US Pac/Vancouver - 1.30am Wednesdays US East/Toronto/Montreal - 4.30am Wednasdays London/GMT - 9.30am Wednesdays Amsterdam/Rome/Paris/Yienna/Prague/Stockholm/Lisbon - 10.30am Wednesdays Pretoria - South Africa - 11.30am Wednesdays Kuwait City - 12.30pm Wednesdays Phillipines - 5.30pm Wednesdays Australia - 5.30pm West AST Wednesdays Australia - 7.30pm AEST Wednesdays Australia - 8.30pm AEDST Wednesdays New Zealand - 9.30pm Wednesdays
Kienbock Disease Australia Support & Information Group
Treatments
Kienbocks
Disease may be treated by immobilization, revascularization, ulnar lengthening
or radial shortening, simple excision, limited intercarpul fusion, or salvage
procedures.
Immobilization
Prolonged
immobilization of the wrist has been tried in all stages of Kienbock's disease.
In some cases it has shown to lead to continued collapse of the lunate. For
Stage I, however, immobilization may be indicated in hopes that the vascular
insult is kept to a minimum and that the lunate is given a chance to heal.
Because diagnosis in this stage is often difficult, a trial period of
immobilization may result in characteristic radiographic changes that establish
the diagnosis.
Revascularization
In
stage II Kienbock's Disease, before the lunate has collapsed, it is possible for
the lunate to regain blood supply.
One
procedure is which a small piece of volar radial bone, still attached to the
pronator quadratus muscle, is grafted to the avascular lunate. This procedure is
done through the volar approach with division of the palmer and transverse
carpul ligaments in order to mobilize the median nerve. After the volar wrist is
entered the lunate is burred with a high speed drill in preparation to receive a
1 to 1.5 cm piece of radial bone still attached to the pronator quadratus
muscle. This is secured with pull out wires or clips.
A
similar revascularization procedure uses the pisiform. Pisiform transfer on its
vascular pedicle. Has found uniformly good results
Another
is described as direct transplanting of a vascular bundle into the vascular
lunate, with successful results.
It must
be remembered, however, that none of the revascularization procedures are likely
to work in the face of severe collapse (stage III), for even if they are
successful in re-establishing blood supply, lunate height and normal carpul
kinematics will not be restored.
Ulna
Lengthening and Radial Shortening
On the
basis of the theory that ulnar minus variance is a significant etiologic factor
in Kienbock's Disease, some have advocated equalization of the distal articular
surfaces by either ulnar lengthening or radial shortening. Both procedures have
had good results reported. However, it seems unlikely that leveling of the
distal articular surfaces of the lunate can restore an already collapsed lunate.
These procedures remain questionable in advanced stage III.
Both
radial shortening and ulnar lengthening require osteotomy. A segment of bone is
removed when radial shortening is done and a segment of bone graft inserted when
ulnar lengthening is done. After either, fixation is usually accomplished with a
compression plate. It is generally recommended that the ulnar variance be
changed to 1 to 2 ml positive variance by placing an appropriate sized
interpositional graft during ulnar lengthening.
Radial
shortening may be preferable to some because it does not require a second
surgical incision to harvest bone graft.
Excision
of the Lunate
Lunate
excision was one of the first surgical procedures for Kienbock's Disease. The
rational of this procedure is to remove sequested bone that is provoking painful
synovitis. Some have reported good results from simple excision others critize
the procedure predicting late proximal migration of the capitate.
Limited
Intercarpul fusion
Its
most important advantage is that radiocarpul motion is maintained, unlike with
complete wrist arthrodesis.
Patients
with severe fragmentation of the lunate undergo resection of the necrotic bone,
osteotomy of the capitate in its mid portion, and proximal displacement of the
proximal capitate fragment, which is secured to the scaphoid and triquetrum with
bone pegs. Essentially, the space vacated by excision of the lunate is filled by
the proximal half of the capitate fragment, and the space left by osteotomy of
the capitate is filled by autogenus bone graft. The procedure is then completed
by performing arthrodesis of contiguous surfaces of the hamate, capitate,
scaphoid and triquetrum by first denuding articular surfaces and securing the
bone with small cortical bone pegs. When the lunate remains suitably intact,
osteotomy of the capitate is omitted, as is lunate excision, and the contiguous
surface of the lunate, scaphoid, triquetrum, hamate and capitate are
arthrodesed.
Kienbock Disease Australia Support & Information Group
Risk
Factors
Different
predisposed risk factors have been implicated in the development of this
Disease. The most commonly cited factors are the interruption of the blood
supply to the lunate, negative ulnar variance, and the workplace environment.
These factors, as well as how to minimize the risk for developing this disease
will be discussed in the following paragraphs
Stahl
believed that in a lunate with an already tenuous blood supply, traumatic
compression fracture leads to avascular necrosis.
Lee
found three vascular patterns in lunates from cadavers: a single vessel, either
volar or dorsal, supplying the entire bone; several vessels at both volar and
dorsal surfaces of the lunate without central anastomosis; and several vessels
at both volar and dorsal surfaces of the lunate with central anastomosis.
Therefore according to Lee, patients with the former two patterns are at greater
risk for developing Kienbock's Disease.
In
fresh specimens, Gelberman and associates also studied the extraossoeus
and intraosseous blood supply of the lunate. They found that in intraosseous
blood supply consisted from three patterns : Y in 59%, I in 31%,
and X in 10%, with dorsal and volar anastomosis just distal to the center
of the lunate. Evaluation of the terminal vessels in the lunate allowed
Gelberman and associates to conclude that the proximal subchondral bone,
adjacent to the radial articular surface, was least vascular. Because of the
rich extraeossis blood supply, they discounted the theory held by some that interruption
of vessels entering a single pole of lunate caused avascularity. Based on the
work, Gelberman and co-workers suggested that it is intraosseous disruption of
vascularity, owing to repeated trauma with compression fracture, that cause
Kienbock's Disease.
Negative
ulnar variance as a risk factor has received considerable attention from the
research community. In 1928, Hulton noted that a short ulnar was present
in 78% of his patients with Kienbock Disease, where as only 23% of normal
patients had a short ulnar. He called this condition ulnar minus variant. Since
the condition was first discovered, many authors have confirmed negative ulnar
variance in patients with Kienbock's disease.
Theoretically,
a short ulnar variance, relative to the distal articular surface of the radius,
causes increased shear and compressive loads on the lunate. Elaborate studies by
Werner and associates proved that altered load transmission through the
radial carpal joint with ulnar minus variance predisposes the radiolunate
articulation to increase loads. This is thought to be a contributing factor in
the development of Kienbock's Disease.
Until
recently, Hulton's findings have been confirmed by many investigators but has
been questioned by others. To date, this controversy has not been resolved. To
make matters more complicated accurate measurement of ulnar variance is not
simple. As pointed out by Epner and Palmer, the apparent variance
changes with the position of the arm.
With
this in mind, Palmer and associates further standardized the method for
determining ulnar variance. They found the position of the distal ulnar, in
relation to the distal radial surface changes with varying degrees of forearm
rotation and that the change in variance was least with the elbow fixed at 90
degrees, The standard view recommended is a poster anterior wrist radiograph
obtained with the patient's shoulder abducted 90 degrees, the elbow flexed 90
degrees, and the forearm in neutral rotation. The importance of accurate
measurement of ulnar variance is highlighted by the recent gain in popularity of
ulnar lengthening and radial shortening techniques to treat Kienbock's Disease
It
appears the effect of aging on ulnar variance supports the theory that negative
ulnar variance is a predisposed risk factor in the development of this disease.
It has been shown by several researchers that ulnar variance increase with age.
The cause of the increase of ulnar variance with aging is unknown, but it might
be due to shortening of the radius because the force of the forearm muscle is
mainly transferred to the radius to developing Kienbock's Disease.
Although
Kienbock's Disease mostly affects young, active males, usually in the 3rd or 4th
decade of life, Yoshida reported that of a 127 cases reviewed, 15
patients were found with aged onset. Among these 15 cases women predominated.
This is a striking difference from Kienbock's Disease in young adults. Other
findings reported from that study revealed that symptoms in elderly are usually
not so severe and conservative treatment is typically effective. It was also
shown that the degree of negative ulnar variance was not as great as in the
young effected population. Several other researchers have shown that the degree
of negative variance is greater in males than in females. This supports the
findings that males are more susceptible.
Besides
the anatomical and biological factors, the workplace also has been implicated as
a contributing factor to the advancement of this disease. Occupations which
require the use of pneumatic tools such as a rivet gun and hammers are all at
particular risk for the development of Kienbock's Disease. The increased impact
loading upon the wrist is thought to be a catalyst for the disruption of the
blood supply to the lunate ultimately leading to its demise. The etiology of
Kienbock's disease is thought to be either repeated minimal trauma or by a
single acute episode. The underlying theme behind the theory of repeated minimal
trauma is repetition coupled with force. Both established Cumulative Trauma
Disorders (CTD) risk factors have been recognized as potentially harmful
elements to the musculoskeletal system. The other proposed etiology, a single
acute episode, indicates that force may be of greater importance. In either
case, ergonomist must evaluate these factors carefully when designing or
redesigning the workplace.
Wrist
posture has been indirectly implied as another possible risk factor for the
development of Kienbock's Disease. In two separate studies, individuals with
cerebral palsy were evaluated because they have a high muscle tone, which is
essentially repeated trauma, and the radiocarpul joint is constantly exposed to
considerably higher pressure than what is found in normal individuals. Rooker
and Goodfellow found five cases of kienbock's Disease in a group of 53
adults with cerebral palsy. An abnormally flexed wrist posture was a common
feature in all five cases. This suggested to them that this extreme posture
compromised the blood supply to the lunate and was considered a contributing
factor to the development of Kienbock's Disease. In a more recent study, Joji
reported that there is increased pressure between the radius and lunate due to
the dynamics conditions so excessive muscle tone characteristics of cerebral
palsy. The resting posture of their subjects was predominantly ulnar flexion
with one case of volar flexion. Joji and associates went on to conclude that it
was unlikely that volar flexion was the cause of Kienbock's Disease. However, in
both studies a resting deviated wrist posture was observed. It is therefore
possible that deviated wrist postures, incorporated with other risk factors
could lead to the development of Kienbock's Disease.
It
appears that the dominant hand of the worker is at the greatest risk for
developing Kienbock's Disease. This finding is consistent with the etiology. In
fact, the majority of the time Kienbock's Disease is unilateral.
Like
many other Cumulative Trauma Disorder's, Kienbock's Disease can be treated by
various medical interventions. Many of these interventions will relieve symptoms
but if the individual is returned to similar activities it is possible to see a
reoccurrence of Kienbock's Disease.
Kienbock Disease Australia Support & Information Group
Diagnosis
of Kienbock's Disease
Kienbock's
Disease is diagnosed radiographically. The characteristic changes of
the lunate include increased density, fracture lines, fragmentation,
and progressive collapse of the lunate.
It
should be distinguished from other causes of wrist pain and swelling
particularly in the early stages.
Disorders
to rule out include rheumatoid arthritis, post traumatic arthritis,
synoval based disease, acute fracture, carpul instability, and ulnar
abutment syndromes. The radiographic hallmark of increased density
seen typically in Kienbock's disease should be distinguished from
transient vascular compromise.
Once
the Diagnosis of Kienbock's Disease is established, the degree of
involvement should be determined in order to assist you through the
many treatment options. Casting for 2 to 3 weeks in uncertain cases
will usually reveal the diagnosis by relative disuse osteoporosis of
the adjacent carpul bones.
Kienbock Disease Australia Support & Information Group
What
is Kienbock's Disease ?
"The
Disease you never hear off or you have never heard off, until you get
it".......( Col Pickering )
Avascular
Necrosis of the Lunate
n:
osteochondrosis affecting the lunate bone - called also lunatomalacia.
Basically,
the blood supply to the lunate bone shuts off, which causes the bone to die,
with eventual collapse of the lunate bone.
As this
is a RARE DISEASE little is known about its causes.
KIENBOCK
ROBERT ( 1871-1953 ) Austrian Radiologist.
Kienbock
pioneered in Radiology. From 1910-1911 he published descriptions
"Concerning Traumatic Malacia of the lunate and its Consequences :
Degeneration and Compression Fractures", descriptions of dislocations of
the hand and a slowly progressive Chronic Osteoitis involving the Lunate Bone.
Kienbock
described the process of Lunatomalacia both the Radiographic changes seen with
the disease, and the clinical symptomatology that accompanied it.
Radiographically,
Kienbock described various changes in the lunate with the vast majority of cases
beginning the disease in the proximal portion, preserving the distal portion
articulating with the capitate. In some radiographs, the shape of the lunate was
preserved and only the internal structure was altered, with radiographs
demonstrating areas of increased intensity. In most radiographs, however, with
the progression of the disease, the shape of the lunate was significantly
affected with the destruction of the proximal portion and loss in height of the
bone.
Kienbock
noted that the disease usually occurred in men in their thirty's and forty's who
were heavy labourers. Frequently they would have an antecedent trauma with
negative radiographs and were diagnosed with a sprain. Overtime, the clinical
course would progress with pain, swelling and restricted motion of the wrist.
Percussion of the third metacarpal ( the hand held in a fist ) produced pain in
the lunate region and when comparing hands shortening of the carpus might be
evident.
Radiographs
demonstrated radiographic changes in the lunate and loosening of the radiocarpul
joint, which Kienbock thought promoted mechanical damage. This loosening
probably referred to the increased radiocarpul space due to synovitis,
proceeding radiocarpul arthrosis.
Kienbock
favoured the view that the condition was due to a disturbance in the nutrition
of the lunate, caused by a rupture of the ligaments from a sprain or
sublixation. Leading to, rather than being a result of compression fractures.
Kienbock
believed that recovery from this disturbed nutrition only occurred in acute
cases, and in late cases, it could be treated only by removal of the lunate.
Usually
at surgery or on a post mortem examination, the lunate was found in two
fragments, as previously described by anatomist's, one volar and one dorsal.
Kienbock Disease Australia Support & Information Group
Stages
of Kienbock's Disease
Kienbock's
Disease follows a specific progressive pattern which is formed into stages.
Initially,
in the early phases of Kienbock's Disease, the changes are localized to the
lunate. In these phases, radiographs reveal increased density, which progresses
to lunate collapse. In the later phases, the pathology involves the mechanical
structure and kinematics of the wrist, not just the lunate. In the more severe
disease, the proximal widens, and rotatory instability of the scaphoid and
diffuses degenerative changes occur.
Stage
I
In
this Stage, radiographs are normal except for the possibility of a linear or
compression fracture that may be shown on tomography. In this phase, bone scan
usually is abnormal, and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is currently
diagnostic.
It
should be noted that MRI was not available for the diagnosis of this disorder
when this classification was devised. Many have suggested that Stage 0 should be
added for those cases in which MRI changes are the only diagnostic clues. It
should be clearly understood that these cases fit into Stage I.
Stage
I was a stage awaiting a diagnostic tool. In fact, Litchman states in his paper
that "radionucleide scanning in stage I may be abnormal, and refinements in
current techniques may soon permit reliable early diagnosis.
Stage
II
Disease
in this Stage is still localized to the lunate. The size, shape, anatomic
relationship, and kinematics of the carpal bones are not significally altered.
The lunate has a definite increased density relative to the other carpal bones.
Late in this Stage, some bone height may be lost on the radial side of the
lunate fracture that may be shown on tomography. In this phase, bone scan
usually is abnormal, and MRI is currently diagnostic.
Stage
III
This
Stage is the transitional one in which the disease begins to affect the carpal
structure and kinematics. At this point, the lunate has collapsed in the frontal
plane and elongated in the sagittal plane. The capitate begins to migrate
proximally. Foreshortening of the scaphoid (the ring sign), scapholunate
dissocation, and ulnar deviation of the triquetrum may or may not be present
radiographically. Measurements of the carpal height ratios, or the lunar
perimeter and lunate area indices, help determine the degree of carpal collapse.
This
transitional Stage is divided into Stages IIIA and IIIB. In Stage IIIA, lunate
collapse occurs without fixed scaphoid rotation and other secondary
derangements.
Stage
IV
All
the findings of Stage III are present as well as generalized degenerative
changes in the carpus. The surface of the adjoining bones affected resulting in
generalized inter-carpal arthritis in the wrist.
Kienbock Disease Australia Support & Information Group
SALVAGE
PROCEDURES in Kienbock's Disease
In
stage IV Kienbock's Disease, good results have been reported with Proximal Row
Carpectomy (PRC) and wrist arthrodesis (total fusion).
Choice
between the two procedures is determined by the needs and desires of the patient
and the integrity of the articular surfaces of the lunate fossa and the
capitate.
Proximal
row carpectomy should be reserved for those people who desire motion over
strength, whereas the wrist fusion is preferable in those people who need
strength. Total wrist arthroplasty is generally contraindicated in young active
people. Treatment choice must be based on a number of variables, including the
experience of the surgeon, the desires and activity level of yourself.
In the
early stages, efforts should be made to salvage the lunate and prevent loss of
normal architecture. In the later stages, efforts should be made to restore that
architecture. In the end stage, normal architecture must be sacrificed to
restore function.
PROXIMAL
ROW CARPECTOMY:
Excising
the proximal carpal row so that the capitate articulates with the lunate fossa
on the radius is rarely indicated, as the capitate and radial articulations are
almost invariable damaged by the disease process to the lunate. However, the
procedure can produce good results in carefully selected cases of wrist arthritis
where the two key articular surfaces are considered to be satisfactory on
radiographic assessment. The proximal carpul bones are excised through a dorsal
approach with dorsal capular repair. The wrist is rested in a cast in neutral
flexion/extension for 4-6 weeks and the mobilized. Power and movement are only
slowly regained but the patient usually obtains 40-60' of flexion/extension
range around the neutral point with moderate grip strength one year after
surgery. If the key articular surfaces were in satisfactory condition
pre-operatively, reasonable pain relief is obtained.
ARTHRODESIS
of the wrist.
Fusion
of an osteoarthritic wrist is most commonly obtained by the use of a plate and
screws to radius, carpus and third metacarpal, augmented with cancellous bone
graft. Slight dorsal angulation potentiates grasp. The dorsal incision extends
to the radius, retracting the extensor indicis proprius compartment radially and
the extensor compartment ulnarly. The dorsal two thirds of the articular
surfaces of the wrist joint are rawed and the cavitates packed with cancellous
bone. Modern low profile plates and screws are not unduly prominent, and there
is normally no need to remove the metal work unless discomfort is experienced.
The stability of the fixation is such that the fingers and the thumb can be
mobilized immediately. The dissection can largely avoid direct exposure of the
extensor tendons, reducing the risk of tendon adhesions.
DENERVATION
of the wrist.
No
attempt is made to treat the arthritis, simply the pain that it causes. The
nerves that supply the carpus are classified into radial, median and ulnar
groups, and a serial nerve blocks will reveal to an extent the likely result of
ablation of these various nerves. An extensive long term study has shown it to
be useful in reducing pain but retaining movement, apparently without the risk
of a Charcot joint. ninety per cent of these series were considered to have
gained reasonable pain relief (60% pain free and 30% improved).
OPERATION
DETAILS
(44
year old patient0
(P2) Bilateral Wrist
Denervation / 3 Incisions on each wrist / 2 Dorsal Incisions / 4th & 5th
Compartments / Posterior Interosseous Nerve divided / Branches of Ulnar Nerve
divided / Volar Curved Incisions / Radial Nerve and Vessel Branches divided /
Anterior Interosseous Nerve and Branches Identified and divided / 20mls
Ropivacaine to each wrist / Vicryl Fat / Nylon Skin / Jelenet/Melolin/Wool/Crepe
POST
OP COMMENTS - Elevate / Home / Reduce dressing 72 hrs / Out Patients Review
2 weeks
Kienbock Disease Australia Support & Information Group
Onset
of Kienbock's Disease
Kienbock'
Disease is an isolated disorder of the lunate resulting from vascular compromise
to the bone. The symptoms include wrist pain, limited range and motion, and
decreased grip strength.
Kienbock's
Disease presents in various forms. The changes in the lunate may be very
localized or diffuse. With progression, the lunate may fracture into two pieces
or crumble into granules or produce an osteochondral fracture from one surface.
The
cartilage is not primarily involved in the pathogenesis and remains relatively
healthy. Bone death occurs over time. Often, a symptomatic wrist will
demonstrate normal X-rays with the diagnosis evident only on MRI. The degree of
loading of the wrist appears to be important and changes in the lunate are
cumulative.
Additional
fault plates may form in other areas of the lunate. This phenomenon is probably
present in most of our carpul bones, but time and avoidance of similar overload
injuries preclude development of multiple plates. Areas in the lunate reach a
critical state in which either a small section or most of the bone becomes
relatively walled off by multiple fault plates and further normal injuries can
no longer heal effectively because the capillary blood supply is inadequate.
Causing the bone to die, providing a significant area further limiting vascular
access.
Changing
one or more of the aetiological factors can halt progression and the necrosis
areas walled off by fault plates can probably heal. Collapsed areas, however,
remained deformed.
Most
cases of Kienbock's disease develop, then, as a result of a long process of
insult which is multifactorial in etiology, producing overload within the
substance of the bone. In the susceptible lunate, miniplanes of injury result in
relatively avascular fault plates, gradually sectioning off areas in the lunate.
Healing in these small areas cannot occur quickly enough if the abnormal loads
and demand continue, ultimately resulting in areas of cell death.
CHAT ROOM: Letting
all members know that there is regular CHAT SESSIONSTens times a
week at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/KienbockDisease_Australia/Chat.
For Real Chat
times refer to Kienbock Disease Australia Chat memo.
It
would be good to see more members in the chat room as it is a fast way of
gathering information, or even if its to get something off your mind, we also
have a bit of a laugh with each other as well.
FILES:
If you have any
information you would like to share, you can list them in Files
section. Also I am currently storing stories for Kienbock Disease The Real Story
PHOTOS:
If you have any
x-rays or photos you wish to share you can place them in the Photosection.
DATABASE:
The Database
has member contact info in it. You are welcome to leave your details there if
you wish.
POLLS:
Letting all
members know that there are some Polls
running and I ASK ALL MEMBERS to fill in these POLLS as it gives us an
idea as a group the differences between our condition of Kienbock's Disease. I
also ask all members to update these POLLS every six months, because as
time goes by, so does your condition change and the operations you may have. All
Polls are strictly confidential.
EDIT
MEMBERSHIP:
If you change
your email address, I ask all members to edit that information on their
membership details, thankyou.
CALENDAR:
If you have any
useful happenings? (operations, birthdays etc...) you can mark them in the Calendar
Also chat topics for the week can be found here.
This
Information is only available to group members,
as non members can only access the home page.
Once again I
welcome all new members, and one day the answer to that question we seek."
How and why did I get Kienbock's Disease ?"
may be answered.
Assistant
Moderator's Adrian (Aust),
Melodie (Partners), Toni (USA), Jay (Canada) and
Birgit (Europe).
Disclaimer All
references to the subject 'Kienbock's Disease' is from members
own personal experiences or personal research done by members.
It should never be taken as 'yes' this will fix me, but we will give you
options of what is available, specialist's in your location to see etc...
and what to look forward to into the future from past experience's.
Subject: Chat Room Feedback. Subject: Group Files Feedback. Subject: Photo Album Feedback. Subject: Group Links Feedback. Subject: Group Database Feedback. Subject: Group Polls Feedback. Subject: Group Calendar Feedback.
I will appreciate any and all responses.
Col Pickering
Group
Owner/Head Moderator
Kienbock
Disease Australia Support and Information Group
Adrian
- Assistant to Head Moderator and Australia / Toni - Assistant Moderator USA / Jay - Assistant Moderator Canada /
Birgit - Assistant Moderator Europe UK / Melodie - Assistant Moderator Partners
of a KD'er
Kienbock Disease Australia Support & Information Group
Chat
memo
Hi there
Gang,
I just
wanted to let you know that the KD OZ Chats have been such a big hit, so much so
that many of us have been in there everyday/night and for many hours.
So I wanted
to let you know that if you have any questions or concerns that you would
like to address right away... or if you would like to just have a chat, come on
in see if someone is there... any time of day or night, 7 days a week, don't be
shy.
Kienbock Disease Australia Support & Information Group
These
are GUIDELINES, not RULES.
A Moderator Message
The main thing is that everyone feels welcome and free to express themselves in
their posts or while in the chat
room. However everyone needs to remember that
this is a community of people that may not share the same beliefs, lifestyle or
philosophy on life, e.g. politics and religion, as each to their own.
Please
respect other people and their beliefs.
Management
of this group find it acceptable for someone to send good wishes like 'god
bless' or similar and if the person this is addressed to does not share the same
beliefs then it is best to take this statement at face value:- "as a good
wish".
Please send feed back to adrian554au@...
all feed back will be kept confidential, Thank you.
i use the wax 3 times a week, only to loosen up the tendons, ligaments and
muscles b4 execising the wrist and fingers.
Col, hope ur feeling better, do u need my meds?, take care,
kathy
>From: "Col Pickering" <KienbockDisease@...>
>Reply-To: KienbockDisease_Australia@yahoogroups.com
>To: <KienbockDisease_Australia@yahoogroups.com>
>Subject: Re: [Kienbock Disease Australia] (unknown)
>Date: Mon, 31 Jan 2005 14:07:20 +1000
>
>Hi and Welcome to the group.
>
>Exogen,. yes I have heard of it but not sure if any member is using it.
>Paraffin Wax, yes I have had the wax treatment, it feels great for a while
>but in reality it didn't do anything for my KD, it may sooth the pain for a
>short while.
>My tip for pain control, is that I have had a bilateral denervation, once
>again it does nothing for your KD, but it has brought my pain level down
>from a 8-9/10 to a 2-3/10.
>As KD is a rare Disease you will find it hard finding a doc or specialist
>who has seen a lot of cases of KD.
>Where are you located? There may be a member in your area who is seeing a
>good doc or specialist.
>take care
>
>Col
>
>
>
>
>----- Original Message -----
>From: "korach55" <korach55@...>
>To: <KienbockDisease_Australia@yahoogroups.com>
>Sent: Monday, January 31, 2005 11:03 AM
>Subject: [Kienbock Disease Australia] (unknown)
>
>
> >
> >
> > Hi,
> > Has anyone heard of or used a treatment called EXOGEN? It is
> > normally used to speed up the healing time for fractures. Has anyone
> > used this before, was it successful? Also, has anyone used parrafin
> > wax to help with pain? Any tips to help control the pain?
> > Also...has anyone's doctor seen lots and lots of patients with
> > kienbock's disease? It seems as if it is a very rare disease, so our
> > doctor only sees about 4 patients a year.
> >
> > Many thanks...
> > Take care
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > Kienbock Disease Australia Support and Information Group.
> > A Friendly Support and Information Group. Our Aim is to help all people
> > who have been Diagnosed with Kienbock's Disease Understand and how to
>Deal
> > with Kienbock's Disease.
> > Post for information to KienbockDisease_Australia@yahoogroups.com or
>Join
> > in the Chat Room,
> > http://groups.yahoo.com/group/KienbockDisease_Australia/chat
> > No matter where you are from your input is important and welcome.
> > Email Group Owner : Col Pickering email:
> > KienbockDisease@... with your comments or further
> > assistance.
> >
> > Yahoo! Groups Links
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
>
>
Kienbock Disease Australia - CHAT THREE - COUPLES CHAT
Wednesday February 2, 2005 12:00 pm
- 4:00 pm
This event repeats every week.
Event Location: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/KienbockDisease_Australia/chat
Notes:
Check your Location for Times
US Pac/Vancouver - 6pm Tuesdays US East/Toronto/Montreal - 9.00pm Tuesdays London/GMT - 2.00am Wednesdays Amsterdam/Rome/Paris/Vienna/Prague/Stockholm/Lisbon - 3.00am Wednesdays Pretoria - South Africa - 4.00am wednesdays Kuwait City - 5.00am Wednesdays Phillipines - 10.00am Wednesdays Western Australia - 10.00am Wednesdays Australia - 12 noon AEST Wednesdays Australia - 1.00pm AEDST Wednesdays New Zealand - 2.00pm Wednesdays
Hi Col,
Glad to see and hear that you are doing so well. I did not realize the
keyhole surgery spots were so small. That was wonderful for you i can only
imagine.
Wishing you a speedy recovery.
Love ya
Toni
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]