Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
ChronicPainCooperate · 'ChronicPainCooperate,''a [CPC] Forum on [http://www.onelist.com] as of 2-25-99, aims to ease *communications* among Chronic P
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Want to share photos of your group with the world? Add a group photo to Flickr.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Fwd: [long] Re: [AdHoc_IDC] Accident with Saa on Malawi airport   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #2323 of 2503 |


---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: l.d.misek-falkoff falkoff <ldmisekfalkoff@...>
Date: Mar 22, 2006 11:41 AM
Subject: [long] Re: [AdHoc_IDC] Accident with Saa on Malawi airport
To: AdHoc_IDC@yahoogroups.com
Cc: akdube@..., disabilityparty@yahoogroups.com, redcorss2005@..., dismissed-as-disabled@yahoogroups.com, ChronicPainCooperate@yahoogroups.com, portal-pwpi@yahoogroups.com, invisible-NO-MORE@yahoogroups.com, cccun@yahoogroups.com, C-O-P-I-N-G_UN@yahoogroups.com, International-Forum-For-Respectful-Interfaces@yahoogroups.com, respectful_interfaces@..., "l.d.misek-falkoff falkoff" < ldmisekfalkoff@...>, Adin Falkoff <adfalkoff@...>

(Retaining longish message as rare occurrence for full background here, I am copying this to the Communications and Coordination Committee for the United Nations discussion online because so many communications and miscommunications issues are inherent.  Another topic for another day is the relation overall of transportation and communication(s) and the historical transitions which in pragmatic terms have taken place but not necessarily as should be accompanied by concerns for values, dignity, and respect).    Could be an 'Industrial Revolution fall-out' but surely always a requisite for truly 'sustainable including equitable development').
 
- - - -
 
Dear Lex and Andre and all involved with the International Disability Convention at the U.N., toward a Treaty::
 
So sorry you have to be the messengers here, but it is truly important that we know this.  There have been other transportation incidents and accidents that we have discussed here. And, pointedly - though at the end of the report - there is this statement:
 
"the transport problems faced by persons with disabilities, sick passengers, mothers with children and elderly persons. "
 
Here is such a kernel of Truth!  I have been in transportation crunches too, and would submit that during them there was the sense that the persons with disabilities are (wrongfully) being considered to be the problems.  The rights based approach here is reflected in the quote above - the problems faced by pwd and not problems caused by pwd.
 
When one observes the procedures put in place at airports, as some of us did (and were part of) during the transport to and from Tunis for the World Summit on the Information Society last November, there was much acting upon pwd rather than partnering with pwd.  In timing, location, etc..  I was in a wheelchair of child size as were others at one airport and its wheels appeared broken and they loaded us last and were running just about into furniture and columns.  In one airport they insisted we have luggage piled on (thrown onto) laps and legs.  Oh that hurt!  It was like they had preconceived notions, or indeed we became part of their performance plans. Being yelled at didn't help either.
 
The *Respectful Interfaces* Programme is looking at these disrespectful interfaces.  We need your reports, we very much are appalled and alarmed and want to be on the team reacting against these abuses. [Please write to join in or inquire].
 
And I know there are untold tales and many here bear them inside the soul.
 
Against these abuses we are working every day.
 
Convention Yes!  And Implementation and Monitoring.  And 'Eternal Vigilance'.
 
Warm regards, Linda M F.

 

On 3/22/06, lex.grandia <lex.grandia@... > wrote:
Dear friends,
 
Below a story, I got from Andre van Deventer from South Africa, just to show one more example of travel difficulties for pwd.
I wonder how they got home later.
 
Lex Grandia
 
 

PRESS STATEMENT

BY ANDREW KUDAKWASHE DUBE

MANAGING DIRECTOR: SAMAITA ASSOCIATES

RESOURCE ADVISOR & MEMBER: DISABLED PEOPLE SOUTH AFRICA (DPSA)

 Telephone/Fax: 0438511561

Email: akdube@...

Cellphone: 0832842232

 Thank you very much for showing interest in this press briefing.

 The subject of this briefing in an unfortunate incident that took place on tarmac of Lilongwe International Airport in Malawi.

 On 17 March 2006, a group of about sixteen persons with disabilities boarded South African Airways Flight from Lilongwe to Johannesburg. After having gone through all the boarding formalities, the disabled passengers were taken to the aircraft for boarding. Half way through the boarding process, and while some of us were in the Passenger Aid Unit vehicle, and on the tarmac, we were informed that the Captain had instructed that we be offloaded the plane for 'safety reason'.

 Half of our disabled passengers who were already in the plane were instructed to leave the plane without any explanation being given. They were told by the senior cabin crew member: 'we will talk outside'. This same senior cabin crew member, who was apparently carrying out the instructions of the Captain, was un-cooperative, visibly angry with us in full view of the other passengers.

 The disabled passengers were then all offloaded and/or man handled to get out of the plane. One disabled person from Botswana forcibly removed from his seat against his will and shunted down the stair case in from of stunned passengers and other crew members in the cabin. He was then grabbed and held in the hands of one member of the ground staff for more than five minutes while they retrieved his wheelchair from the hold. This humiliating episode was all done in full view of passengers and ground staff.

 Some of the disabled persons were then forced into a waiting bus, and those of us in the PAU were denied permission to talk to the Captain or to join our colleagues who gathered on the tarmac waiting to either board the flight or to obtain an explanation from the Captain.

 A lady who had a broken hip, and accompanied by her daughter for urgent medical treatment in South Africa was also offloaded against her will and in severe pain as they spirited her out of the aeroplane and down the staircase.

 Having been driven back to the main terminal building against our will, some members of our group then started moving back to the aeroplane accompanied by ground security in order to obtain an explanation from the Captain. We were stopped halfway towards the aircraft which, at that time still had its doors open.

 While we waited, we were also joined by our Guest, Mr Mark Harrison, from the Overseas Development Group (ODG), University of East Anglia in the UK. He refused to go back into plane if we were left behind. As we waited, we were shocked to watch the Captain or a member of his crew in the cockpit, open the windows of the cockpit and throwing down to a ground staff Mr Mark Harrision' hand language and taking off with our checked in language.

 We content that the Captain acted in a manner that was disrespectful in treated us the way we were treated on this flight. Options for our care and assistance on board were never explored. Our dignity was violated.

 We feel that we were discriminated against on the basis of our disability and the general attitude of the Captain and his purser was both negative and dehumanising.

 By carrying our unaccompanied luggage and leaving us on the tarmac, we feel the Captain and his purser severely compromised the very safety clauses that they purported to uphold.

The workshop in Malawi was about disseminating the results of research that found out there is a serious lack of implementation of policies that protect and safeguard the rights of persons with disabilities.

The South African version of this workshop will be implemented from 22-24 March 2006. In all we invited more than thirty governments and only two have confirmed their attendance up to now.

 With regard to this particular incident, we are in the process of exploring all legal options and phases of action at our disposal.

 In addition, we would like to call on SAA to implement a well targeted awareness raising work among all its personnel in order to ensure that persons with disabilities, sick passengers and elderly persons do not have their rights violated in the process of implementing safety regulations.

 Furthermore, we urge the Department of Transport and all invited government departments, to participate in the forthcoming workshop in order to obtain advice and support on how to integrate persons with disabilities in their work.

 This was only but one incident that is not different from similar incidents that take in the public transport sector in South Africa. We urge the Department to provide funding and facilitate the implementation of their own strategies for the transport sector including the Disabled Accessibility Transport Environment (DATE) Programme that was designed specifically to deal with and effectively address the transport problems faced by persons with disabilities, sick passengers, mothers with children and elderly persons.

 


--
With best wishes, L. D. Misek-Falkoff, Ph.D., J.D.
For Identification:
National Disability Party
International Disability Caucus
Communications Coordination Committee for the U.N.  *Respectful Interfaces* [RESPITES]
and  *International Forum For Respectful Interfaces* [IFFRI] .

Wed Mar 22, 2006 6:24 pm

ldmisekfalkoff@...
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #2323 of 2503 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

... From: l.d.misek-falkoff falkoff <ldmisekfalkoff@...> Date: Mar 22, 2006 11:41 AM Subject: [long] Re: [AdHoc_IDC] Accident with Saa on Malawi airport ...
l.d.misek-falkoff fal...
ldmisekfalkoff@...
Send Email
Mar 22, 2006
6:24 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help