The following is a forwarded message from another email list, which originated in yet another email list. This email is initiated with my reply to the original message being forwarded to me. I thought the members of the group might enjoy reading the original message (which follows mine) and/or my reply.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I greatly enjoyed reading the other individual's experience with journalling her memories. I have found a similar cathartic release of intense emotions (anguish, panic, outrage, fear). When I initially started writing of my experiences, I had to remember the last (at that time) 7 years in order to file for disability (otherwise my personal input would have been a blank). I had no understanding of myself at the time, nor of what my difficulties were and how these difficulties were associated with my problems in functioning within the public/private domain. In other words, I was unable to explain why I was applying for disability and how I had come to such a predicament.
I used my resume and with a month's effort (day & night) managed to remember (painfully, while walking on the surreal plane), an example memory of what had occurred psychologically with each loss of employment/education. The following year I managed to obtain an archaic computer that was not supposed to be able to function on the internet (It still is - with heavy maintenance). I enrolled in support groups and accidentally struck-up a daily email exchange with a pen-pal. In these daily email efforts I didn't discuss myself (initially) so much as provide peer-support (empathy-streaming).
Empathy may be something one gives in support of others, but always one is unwittingly and indirectly accessing one's own pain. In doing so, I discovered memory without the volatility of abreactive flashbacks (extremely debilitating in every way conceivable). Although mildly dissociated when writing like this, I found I did not lose myself in the dissociative experience, but was somehow refreshed. To my knowledge there is only one website that offers pen-pals on the internet (Gift from Within). As I was/am on welfare, I was unable to get the necessary $5/one time U.S. together to join. I hope to do so this spring. How come public medical will fund drugs, but not such a cheap alternative to drugs. I have not, do not take drugs for my biopsychiatrically-labelled "mental 'illness'".
Being a caregiver has been my life! Being cut-off from this avenue of expression was a form of repression for me. I decided that I wanted to keep some of my emails as they 'expressed' myself. I began the construction of my website via yahoo freebie. The first page was my philosophy page. Until recently I would spend anywhere from 4 to 24 hours/day, frequently 7days/week working at these avenues of self-expression. I liken the whole experience to that of someone painting survivor art. I have gained back my memory of the last, now 9 years. I also have over 100 journal entries. I rarely recognize myself in what I write. There are rarely any details pertinent to me, but are more given to philosophical insight through a maturation process of understanding. As with my website what I write shows where my interests lie and what I am doing to self-educate in these areas.
I also completed a business plan. This too was cathartic (PARO - Nor' West Ontario, Women's Self-Employment Program), as I reviewed (without memory, other than my resume) what sorts of alternatives might have been helpful in the preceding 8 years. Ofcourse social services thought that I was doing this for reasons other than therapeutic. My resistance to satisfying their needs caused me to be in crisis (including suicidal) perhaps 50% of the time. My first couple of business plans, written while taking the training program were what I could have done a decade ago. Although the program lasted 3 months, I kept my biz plan going until recently when I finally focused it into a mold that I can visualize myself doing (p/t) in the near future.
These alternatives have one thing in common and that is (like art) they create a public personna for that which is an internal and unreachable (accept in crisis) aspect of self. In doing so they create an emotional calm where there was unknown turmoil directly resulting in non-functionality. This catharsis is done in an 'indirect' manner where I am slightly removed from what would otherwise create extremes of conflicting emotion, dissociation, flashbacks, insomnia, food disorders, inability for stable, interpersonal communication, etcetera. It comes out of oneself - naturally - rather than imposed and geared to suit someone else's agenda. This 'intra-personal' communication is therefore a healing experience, rather than re-traumatizing and as such an enhancement of one's dysfunctionality due to an ingraining of the debilitation of severe emotional distress.
Lately I have begun to lose interest in the last decade, which I believe is a good signal. Like I am slowly turning my back on a personally, horrific experience spanning almost a decade, that has been 'grappled' with, understood and can be let go of. I feel the need to move on and to leave the past, as the past or to become active rather than reactive. My outrage, fear, anxiety, panic is no longer something that is an irratic, yet imminent expression of self that stems from personal pain and anguish. I feel an alienation from that part of self rather than owned by it. I am not so afraid to talk to someone (most of the time), out of fear for being triggered into an overwhelming, personally-felt, disgraceful state-of-being. I also recognize that my present welfare, disability exemption has provided me with a respite space to escape the psychological warzone that left me consistently being triggered into an ever reduced state of physiological and psychological debilitation,
which continued to worsen with each year as my physical/cognitive
/emotional well-being became drained of its endurance. Such that I found myself 'becoming the personas' of flashback experiences, alienated from the person I am, my character no longer recognizeable to me.
I do feel intense bitterness towards a 'single' image of mental health as that dictated by a dominant (and dominating), academic, cultural system that denigrates the host of alternatives that people have found helpful (and say so) in favour of oppressing, repression of pharmaceuticals (public) and psychoanalysis (private), which many people do not find helpful (and say so): A system that denies the reality of our human need to feel our daily lives, the good and the bad, and our human capacity to absorb both as an integral part of self: A system that is so obviously enraptured within its academic elitism and cultural affiliations: A system that is so clearly alligned with social control in its upholding a vertical hierarchical system of 'isms' rather than undermining it: A system that redefines the norms of human behaviour as "mental 'illness'" and a product of faulty genetic make-up intrinsic to the individual and hence innate to their 'group' affiliation.
The following link for "A Doctor's Toxic Shock" by Nanette Gartrell
http://www.nytimes.com/2004/01/04/magazine/04LIVES.html is well worth reading. A "psychiatrist in practice for 27 years" failed to recognize herself having anxiety and depression (suffering from grief and loss for the death of loved ones and the fatal illness of a close friend). She immediately went for the pill bottle. She suffered adverse side-effects. She was undeterred and continued the drugs. Her 'learned' peer group were of no help. She researched in academic journals and the internet looking to see herself in their listings of adverse side-effects, but to no avail. She talked to another user of the drug who was able to recognize and acknowledge similar experiences with the drug ("His symptoms were similar to mine. He said it was like coming off a coke high, that he would choose grief any day over bupropion"). She found a journal entry that stated that some
people's genetics can't cope with the drug. She tapered off the drug and hasn't been depressed since! So she thinks that she has learned her lesson: "After taking bupropion, I describe potential side effects to my patients in much greater detail...If a patient complains of symptoms similar to mine, I switch meds immediately. In the past, I would have encouraged the patient to stick it out, anticipating that most side effects would eventually pass." Truth is - she hasn't learned a damn thing and everything she says is proof of that. She (like her 'blind, deaf and dumb' learned peers) is as ignorant as she was prior to her experience.
This aforementioned psychiatrist makes me want to join a Native Healing Circle and to participate in a Cleansing Ceremony so that I could rid myself of the 'filth' of the dominant culture's disdain and contempt for our humanity.
Katie
> ----- Original Message -----
> From: Ustun Ongel
> To: critical psychiatry
> Sent: Tuesday, January 06, 2004 3:31 PM
> Subject: [criticalpsychiatry] Fw: Letter to Psychologists,
Therapists and Psychiatrists
>
> This came from another e-group. You may visit the web site
www.aaacworld.org (Adults Abused as Children Worldwide) for further information.
>
> Ustun Ongel, PhD
> social psychologist, Univ. of Cukurova, Faculty of Education,
Balcali, Adana, Turkey, 01330
> tel: 90.322. 338 71 50 (work); 457 74 50 (home)
> uongel at cu.edu.tr
> uongel at ttnet.net.tr
>
> --------------
I would like to begin my appeal to you on a feeling, human level by describing my personal experience as a patient.
In 1993, after writing about the abuse in my childhood, I was depressed; in fact, I wanted to die rather than live with the pain and agony of childhood memories and flashbacks. I knew I needed help and scheduled an appointment with an HMO therapist. The waiting period at the time was 12 weeks, before I could see a therapist. I was very depressed and anxiety stifled my assertiveness, and I had no choice other than to surrender to the `modus operandi'. In addition, besides feeling helpless, I blamed and judged myself for needing help. As in my childhood, I surrendered to the power of the "higher authority," to the experts who supposedly knew what they were doing. In these twelve weeks of waiting, a significant transformation was going on in my brain: in spite of my depressed condition, I felt for the first time a wholesome "defrosting" of my brain. In a sense, the mentally reliving of the trauma through writing it down, affected the depression and started a healing process. I felt how frozen, locked away pictures of traumatic memories started melting into consciousness. The impact of the trauma that was force-frozen thirty years ago, began to finish, to complete an unfinished process. Finally, I felt the loose ends (neurons) in my brain try to connect. Every triggered event I felt while in my childhood memories, ended in a flashback. I began to understand why I was in fear all my life. These flashbacks helped me to finish many stuck past traumatic experience to process. I began with a cognitive connecting which lead me to the original source, to a feeling way, and to the source of my over forty year old trauma and fear. Thereafter, the imprinted fear was no longer as devastating; it lost the power because the agony and fear that was attached to the memory was felt first and later, gone. I no longer felt the helpless, childlike emotional feelings (a child who has no words to express). The loose ends had now connected with a functional left hemisphere, and I could explain and express the feeling with the words of an adult, what I was unable to say as an child. My hope to receive help in continuing this healing process was enormous.
After finally meeting my therapist for the first time, this
vital healing process was violently interrupted. I was sent to a psychiatrist, and the result was Wellbutrin, in conjunction with cognitive therapy. I explained my needs to the therapist, that I would like to continue with regressing and feeling but I was not understood. After about 10 sessions, I felt her helplessness when I did not adopt her theory of "managing"/repressing the pain. I wanted to heal, I told her, not repress again, but she did not understand. After the 20th session with her she threw her hands helplessly up in the air, asking me, "What theory fits you?" I do not need a theory, I told her, just help me to heal by answering questions to many feelings I have and can't understand. She indicated that I would not understand her
explanations because I do not have her level of psychological
education. Instead of receiving help, I was again stifled and
insulted.
> From: Ustun Ongel
> To: critical psychiatry
> Sent: Tuesday, January 06, 2004 3:31 PM
> Subject: [criticalpsychiatry] Fw: Letter to Psychologists,
Therapists and Psychiatrists
>
> This came from another e-group. You may visit the web site
www.aaacworld.org (Adults Abused as Children Worldwide) for further information.
>
> Ustun Ongel, PhD
> social psychologist, Univ. of Cukurova, Faculty of Education,
Balcali, Adana, Turkey, 01330
> tel: 90.322. 338 71 50 (work); 457 74 50 (home)
> uongel at cu.edu.tr
> uongel at ttnet.net.tr
>
> --------------
I would like to begin my appeal to you on a feeling, human level by describing my personal experience as a patient.
In 1993, after writing about the abuse in my childhood, I was depressed; in fact, I wanted to die rather than live with the pain and agony of childhood memories and flashbacks. I knew I needed help and scheduled an appointment with an HMO therapist. The waiting period at the time was 12 weeks, before I could see a therapist. I was very depressed and anxiety stifled my assertiveness, and I had no choice other than to surrender to the `modus operandi'. In addition, besides feeling helpless, I blamed and judged myself for needing help. As in my childhood, I surrendered to the power of the "higher authority," to the experts who supposedly knew what they were doing. In these twelve weeks of waiting, a significant transformation was going on in my brain: in spite of my depressed condition, I felt for the first time a wholesome "defrosting" of my brain. In a sense, the mentally reliving of the trauma through writing it down, affected the depression and started a healing process. I felt how frozen, locked away pictures of traumatic memories started melting into consciousness. The impact of the trauma that was force-frozen thirty years ago, began to finish, to complete an unfinished process. Finally, I felt the loose ends (neurons) in my brain try to connect. Every triggered event I felt while in my childhood memories, ended in a flashback. I began to understand why I was in fear all my life. These flashbacks helped me to finish many stuck past traumatic experience to process. I began with a cognitive connecting which lead me to the original source, to a feeling way, and to the source of my over forty year old trauma and fear. Thereafter, the imprinted fear was no longer as devastating; it lost the power because the agony and fear that was attached to the memory was felt first and later, gone. I no longer felt the helpless, childlike emotional feelings (a child who has no words to express). The loose ends had now connected with a functional left hemisphere, and I could explain and express the feeling with the words of an adult, what I was unable to say as an child. My hope to receive help in continuing this healing process was enormous.
After finally meeting my therapist for the first time, this
vital healing process was violently interrupted. I was sent to a psychiatrist, and the result was Wellbutrin, in conjunction with cognitive therapy. I explained my needs to the therapist, that I would like to continue with regressing and feeling but I was not understood. After about 10 sessions, I felt her helplessness when I did not adopt her theory of "managing"/repressing the pain. I wanted to heal, I told her, not repress again, but she did not understand. After the 20th session with her she threw her hands helplessly up in the air, asking me, "What theory fits you?" I do not need a theory, I told her, just help me to heal by answering questions to many feelings I have and can't understand. She indicated that I would not understand her
explanations because I do not have her level of psychological
education. Instead of receiving help, I was again stifled and
insulted.
Shortly after, I searched for another therapist. In the first session with her, I conveyed my wish for answers and
assistance in my healing and described again that I would need to make connection to my panic attacks and the constant present fear. Annoyed, she told me "there is no need for you to know how to analyze." Now, feeling helpless again, I left her as well and continued with Wellbutrin. Slowly I became aware of some side-effects of the antidepressants and mentioned my weight gain to my psychiatrist and other new symptoms, such as shell fish and chocolate allergies, insomnia and emphysema. He told me harshly that it was menopause and not Wellbutrin that caused my weight gain, and disregarded all other side-effects I mentioned. After being on Wellbutrin for 4 years, I had gained 65 pounds, in spite of eating less than ever.
assistance in my healing and described again that I would need to make connection to my panic attacks and the constant present fear. Annoyed, she told me "there is no need for you to know how to analyze." Now, feeling helpless again, I left her as well and continued with Wellbutrin. Slowly I became aware of some side-effects of the antidepressants and mentioned my weight gain to my psychiatrist and other new symptoms, such as shell fish and chocolate allergies, insomnia and emphysema. He told me harshly that it was menopause and not Wellbutrin that caused my weight gain, and disregarded all other side-effects I mentioned. After being on Wellbutrin for 4 years, I had gained 65 pounds, in spite of eating less than ever.
I changed psychiatrists in 1998 and the new one switched me to Effexor. Additional fresh hope arrived in 1999 when I heard about EMDR and entered the therapies with an EMDR specialist. After many private sessions, I found another EMDR therapist inside my HMO and switched for financial reasons. After one and half years, I found out to my dismay, that EMDR had done nothing to heal my fear and anxiety attacks. It helped only as a temporary suppressor. The symptoms reappeared again shortly after I stopped EMDR therapy.
In 2000, I gathered my little remaining strength, quit
all "therapies", and got off antidepressants. After three months of withdrawal effects from Effexor, the veil in my cloudy brain was lifted and slowly I began to live again on a feeling level. The most shocking part was for me was that nothing had changed after being on antidepressants nearly 7 years. All the symptoms I had before were still there. The anxiety attacks and my childhood trauma were still alive, just as they were in 1993, before I began with antidepressants. The only difference was that I was a walking zombie for 7 years, with depression.
All I got from antidepressants was some loss of my short-term memory, 65 pounds, and new allergies. The effects of my childhood trauma were still present, actively diminishing my life. Why, in the name of humanity, I asked the psychiatrist, did I have to take these dangerous drugs? Silence was the answer and no advice was given to me about how to heal my mental agony. As I found out too late, Wellbutrin had slowed down everything in my body, even my thyroid. Off and on, my cortisol level was down to 4.8. One of my symptoms, emphysema, did disappear. The shell fish and chocolate allergies remain until today.
The tip of the iceberg was the 60 hours cognitive therapy (with four different therapists), were wasted years and brought no more than false hope and was no more than pain-management meaning again suppression/oppression/repression of consciousness of mental pain. I did not want to manage my pain, I wanted to heal from the wounds of severe childhood abuse. Naturally, neither Wellbutrin nor cognitive therapy could do this. Dependent like every patient, I had to trust the medical professionals. My concern about weight gain and the still lingering anxiety attacks were not heard. What can a patient do who suffers from constant depression, anxiety, and fears, other
than believe the one who supposed to help? After three years on
Effexor, I had lost an enormous amount of my short-term memory. Knowing I would not receive the help I needed, I did address
most of the symptoms myself. I chose to consciously address the
past, my RCT (repressed childhood trauma) in a self-regressive
therapy. I allowed stuck memories to surface and two times I
traveled to my home town to face the reality of the past. I felt and released the pain which finished the process of the stuck trauma. With this natural step by step process and the support from empathetic friends, who did not label or stifle me with theories or the projection of their own limitations, a natural healing took place. Now after three years, I can call myself a mentally strong human being, free from the effects of early trauma.
In 2000, I gathered my little remaining strength, quit
all "therapies", and got off antidepressants. After three months of withdrawal effects from Effexor, the veil in my cloudy brain was lifted and slowly I began to live again on a feeling level. The most shocking part was for me was that nothing had changed after being on antidepressants nearly 7 years. All the symptoms I had before were still there. The anxiety attacks and my childhood trauma were still alive, just as they were in 1993, before I began with antidepressants. The only difference was that I was a walking zombie for 7 years, with depression.
All I got from antidepressants was some loss of my short-term memory, 65 pounds, and new allergies. The effects of my childhood trauma were still present, actively diminishing my life. Why, in the name of humanity, I asked the psychiatrist, did I have to take these dangerous drugs? Silence was the answer and no advice was given to me about how to heal my mental agony. As I found out too late, Wellbutrin had slowed down everything in my body, even my thyroid. Off and on, my cortisol level was down to 4.8. One of my symptoms, emphysema, did disappear. The shell fish and chocolate allergies remain until today.
The tip of the iceberg was the 60 hours cognitive therapy (with four different therapists), were wasted years and brought no more than false hope and was no more than pain-management meaning again suppression/oppression/repression of consciousness of mental pain. I did not want to manage my pain, I wanted to heal from the wounds of severe childhood abuse. Naturally, neither Wellbutrin nor cognitive therapy could do this. Dependent like every patient, I had to trust the medical professionals. My concern about weight gain and the still lingering anxiety attacks were not heard. What can a patient do who suffers from constant depression, anxiety, and fears, other
than believe the one who supposed to help? After three years on
Effexor, I had lost an enormous amount of my short-term memory. Knowing I would not receive the help I needed, I did address
most of the symptoms myself. I chose to consciously address the
past, my RCT (repressed childhood trauma) in a self-regressive
therapy. I allowed stuck memories to surface and two times I
traveled to my home town to face the reality of the past. I felt and released the pain which finished the process of the stuck trauma. With this natural step by step process and the support from empathetic friends, who did not label or stifle me with theories or the projection of their own limitations, a natural healing took place. Now after three years, I can call myself a mentally strong human being, free from the effects of early trauma.
Now I am dealing with the leftover effects from Wellbutrin and Effexor, which include a very slow metabolism, and a partial loss of short-term memory. Finally, I would like to tell you that meanwhile I have been contacted by many Adults Abused as Children who have told me, not only their experienced trauma, but also their disgraceful experiences with their psychiatrists, psychologists and therapists. In their helplessness they have reached out to many organizations, even churches for help. Some of them have been in therapy for more then a decade without any progress. Most of them are on antidepressants and/or have been re-programmed by different therapies, and learned a new way of repressing their trauma. Some are indoctrinated by religion and believe now that the blind obedience to a god will change and heal their lives.
The effects of early childhood trauma, anxiety, depression will be alive as long as the trauma remains unprocessed. Other disorders and side-effects will dominate the life of all who have not been given the opportunity to heal. I have met only a handful of therapists who agree with me that mental healing can take place if we allow it, support and assist the process with empathy on a human non-judgmental/or labeling level, and without limiting the help-seekers with theories. Unfortunately, most people in the psychological profession do not have the tools needed for such a big task. Often, I believe the therapist her/himself is most incapable of providing such empathetic assistance because of their own CTE (childhood trauma effects) which lead them to act out their unconscious childhood emotions instead of partnering in their clients' healing.
My plea to all professionals is:
Respect the human being. Support their clients in becoming more aware of their inner selves and answer their questions without assuming your superiority. Apply your education wisely and only as a tool to liberate instead of creating a new dependency and helplessness in indoctrination or theories. Teach the young psychologists (in addition to the curriculum), the most vital learning: that a human being is born with a fully intact right hemisphere, and remains throughout life a creature with a right to her/his feelings. Most of all I urge those who choose psychology or psychiatry for personal reasons, to heal and feel your own trauma first, before applying left hemisphere knowledge on others in pain. After all, healing mental/emotional pain cannot come from left hemisphere knowledge alone, because we all are born with the perfect functional right hemisphere, with feelings; It is these feelings that are damaged and destroyed by abuse and trauma.
Sieglinde Alexander
end of file/...
The effects of early childhood trauma, anxiety, depression will be alive as long as the trauma remains unprocessed. Other disorders and side-effects will dominate the life of all who have not been given the opportunity to heal. I have met only a handful of therapists who agree with me that mental healing can take place if we allow it, support and assist the process with empathy on a human non-judgmental/or labeling level, and without limiting the help-seekers with theories. Unfortunately, most people in the psychological profession do not have the tools needed for such a big task. Often, I believe the therapist her/himself is most incapable of providing such empathetic assistance because of their own CTE (childhood trauma effects) which lead them to act out their unconscious childhood emotions instead of partnering in their clients' healing.
My plea to all professionals is:
Respect the human being. Support their clients in becoming more aware of their inner selves and answer their questions without assuming your superiority. Apply your education wisely and only as a tool to liberate instead of creating a new dependency and helplessness in indoctrination or theories. Teach the young psychologists (in addition to the curriculum), the most vital learning: that a human being is born with a fully intact right hemisphere, and remains throughout life a creature with a right to her/his feelings. Most of all I urge those who choose psychology or psychiatry for personal reasons, to heal and feel your own trauma first, before applying left hemisphere knowledge on others in pain. After all, healing mental/emotional pain cannot come from left hemisphere knowledge alone, because we all are born with the perfect functional right hemisphere, with feelings; It is these feelings that are damaged and destroyed by abuse and trauma.
Sieglinde Alexander
end of file/...
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Hotjobs: Enter the "Signing Bonus" Sweepstakes
Private_MindSpace<